A. Richardson+ for a 2024 1st?

[sugbear65]

This is for a 12 team, 1QB, PPR, 1/4PPC league

I was offered-

-A. Richardson, 2024 2nd(mid), 2024 3rd(early)
For
- 2024 1st(likely 3-6 range, from a non playoff team)

I am a competitive team, top 3 roster. Currently have Dak, Russ, and Geno at QB. Has been frustrating as I pick the wrong guy every week. Could use a set it and forget it QB1. And the 1/4PPC helps boost A. Rich numbers a tiny bit. Is this worth the price, or should I hold onto my early-ish 1st round pick? It’s currently the only pick I own for next year.

[krtbuckeye]

I would hold the 1st over Richardson in 1QB, but definitely understand the valuation with Richardson’s rushing upside. I would just want it to be a bit later 1st if giving for a QB in the format (outside of Mahomes, Allen, Hurts)

[Gator Sens]

With the potential the 1st ends up in the 1.03 range, I think you are giving too much in a 1 QB format. Hold.

[sugbear65]

Thanks guys. The 1st is likely gonna be the 1.03-1.05. We do points possible for slotting picks on non playoff teams. There are two teams in full rebuild that are horrible and have 1.01 and 1.02 on lock most likely. Then, as I see it, this team and another are vying for 1.03 and 1.04. Don’t see any way they make the playoffs.
If I could get the potential 2.01 or 2.02 instead of a mid 2nd, does that make a difference for you, or still too rich in 1 QB?

[krtbuckeye]

It’s not that I necessarily am not a Richardson believer, but I think if giving the 1.03-1.04 range in 1QB, I’d only do that for a more proven QB commodity. Again, can definitely see the upside though. I don’t think bumping the 2nd up would sway me too much.