Which side

[Zech13]

12 team SF start 10 (2rb, 3 wr)

Toney/ 24 3rd or AJ Dillon

[tstafford]

Toney by a mile IMO.

[Gator Sens]

I don't really like either side but Dillon remains behind Jones, so on paper Toney has the better shot but I have very little faith in him as a fantasy asset. It comes down to if you need RB or WR help more...go with the side where you need the most help.

[Stone2987]

Toney is a lottery ticket, Dillon is a reliable low end weekly starter. If you have a stacked roster or are completely rebuilding, I’d prefer the upside of Toney. If you’re somewhere in the middle and need an end of the lineup guy to get you startable points every week, I’d prefer Dillon.

[Tvols]

Toney.

[Anteaters]

Toney is a lottery ticket, Dillon is a reliable low end weekly starter.

++
I'd take AJD every time. Good floor, with upside to borderline RB1 if he gets to start. Toney is a $5 scratch-off that might "hit" for flex (for a season), but has a floor beneath the basement.

[TheTroll]

Toney is a lottery ticket, Dillon is a reliable low end weekly starter.

++
I'd take AJD every time. Good floor, with upside to borderline RB1 if he gets to start. Toney is a $5 scratch-off that might "hit" for flex (for a season), but has a floor beneath the basement.

Good Analogy! AJD for me too

[killer_of_giants]

i see dillon as an RB2 with RB1 upside for a couple of seasons at least.

toney is a gimmicky player that had 2 games with more than 10 points last season. taller tavon austin, with LESS draft capital and work ethic.

[frerichs5]

Give me the lottery ticket. Dillon was RB35 last year in PPG. 10 games in a row under 10 points. That’s just not a RB I care much about. If both players hit their ceiling, Toney will be more valuable. If both hit their floors, who cares. If both remain the same as they have been, who cares.