Please help with this trade offer

[kris_kapsner]

I have a contending team in a 16 team league. I'm a bit thin at WR depth after my top two studs of Adams and Metcalf, and I only own 1 1st round pick over the next three years. The pick I own is from the owner of the worst team in our league for 2022.

My WR's are:
Adams
Metcalf
Fuller
Callaway
Sterling Shepard
Sammy Watkins
James Proche
Tyrell Williams


The rest of my team is:
QB: Russell Wilson, Zach Wilson
RB: Barkley, Chubb, Hunt, Mixon, Gio
TE: Kelce, Pitts, Njoku, Seals-Jones

I received this offer:

Brandon Aiyuk and Corey Davis
for
Sterling Shepard and the very good 1st round pick next year (probably #1 or #2 overall)

Would you do the trade?

[mill101911]

No not at all. Your studs can carry the load, but once Shepard is back, he can fill in. That pick is will be a very solid player.

[HughHoney]

Definitely not. I’d be ok shopping the pick but would need a much better return than Aiyuk+Davis.

[PigeonBoys]

I wouldn’t do this trade either, that project top end pick better get a proven guy in return. I’ve never been a Davis fan and Aiyuk is clearly not the #1 in SF. I’d rather try and trade kelce with Pitts ascending. That way you can likely pick up an alpha WR which helps you more long term IMO.

[Gator Sens]

Piling on, pass on this deal and hold the pick or wait for a much better offer to come through. I'm not ready to pack it in on Aiyuk, but this is way too pricey.

[OhSnapItsAnt]

I would NOT do the offer as is but I’d definitely be trying to get it done somehow without the 1st if possible.

The emergence of Toney makes me think Shepard won’t produce like he was in the beginning of the season and as much as I’m not a fan of Aiyuk, I still think he’s a buy low.