Out of 2017 contention trade...

[bigern1000]

Pretty much out of contention for 2017, looking ahead to next year. PPR dynasty...

I give D Henry, Hilton and H Henry

I get E McGuire, ODB and G Olson

Just looking to get a couple of thoughts - thanks...

[Sgtpsych]

Love the obj side here

[Slackalacker]

Get OBJ yes definitely worth it. Then try and get rid of Olsen or if you can get a 2nd instead if him then even better.

[Goddard]

Initial instinct said OBJ, but I think it's close.

[vixen]

Initial instinct said OBJ, but I think it's close.

that is how i feel...and i love OBJ

could you get someone other than olsen? (or mcguire for that matter)

[skip]

I don't like it. Hilton is a top 10 WR and then you are adding both Henrys to get OBJ, a nearly useless RB and am aging Olsen? If you're out of contention, you should not be giving up this much of your future.

[The Red Rooster]

I don't like it. Hilton is a top 10 WR and then you are adding both Henrys to get OBJ, a nearly useless RB and am aging Olsen? If you're out of contention, you should not be giving up this much of your future.

My thoughts exactly...especially the end.

[BradysBunch]

i dont like it. if you are looking for the future...you have it with those 3 players.

[sloth8u]

Keep your guys.

[jaykay22]

I'd rather keep the trio you have, honestly. TY is ELITE, should continue to be very good for another 2-3 years at least, and you'd be giving up waaaaay too early on Derrick Henry and Hunter Henry, when those should be pieces to build around.

[diamonddave]

the rare time you may go AGAINST the cardinal rule of getting the best player in the deal, which is clearly OBJ. but playing for the future...
D.Henry is much better than Elijah
H.Henry over Olsen
TY with Luck back is definitely not as good at OBJ but OBJ's only elite when he's on the field. i'd keep your guys and don't trade just to shake things up. at the end of the day, talent wins

[vixen]

Initial instinct said OBJ, but I think it's close.

that is how i feel...and i love OBJ

could you get someone other than olsen? (or mcguire for that matter)

geez, i think i have had a change of heart..i would take OBJ here...would like it more if you got a 2nd round pick instead of olsen though

[Edgy68]

I'd rather keep the trio you have, honestly. TY is ELITE, should continue to be very good for another 2-3 years at least, and you'd be giving up waaaaay too early on Derrick Henry and Hunter Henry, when those should be pieces to build around.

Sounds like the guy is making a push to remain competitive this year while still cashing OBJ for his highest possible value. You might be able to get him for less. If anything, I'd try a counter where you add a different asset or pick to TY to get OBJ. Leave the Henry's out of it. They are build-around material.

[CD_23]

As a newbie to posting may I suggest adding your current roster either in your signature or in the post. Helps to add context for this trade.
In a vacuum I would take the OBJ side but it’s fairly close.
I still can’t buy into TY being an elite WR and both Henry’s are the ‘potential’ studs everyone’s waiting for.
OBJ is the best in this deal by a lot and McGuire looks to have a future in that backfield (whatever that’s worth on the Jets), Olsen may have another year or two of solid production and its possible you already have a 2nd TE or can grab one from the waiver. Again, context.

[sjwill]

OBJ is a great piece to rebuild around.