Either of these reasonable returns for Cooper?

[Buckhill Bombers]

Offer A

Give: A. Cooper, Morris, C. Michael
Get: 1.1, 1.5, 2.1

Offer B

Give: A. Cooper, 1.8
Get: 1.1, Michael Thomas

12 team PPR league

[Goddard]

Offer A isn't bad, but I'd take B in a heart beat. Cooper and Thomas aren't that far off in value right now, so you're giving up the 1.08 for 1.01. Even if you prefer Amari over Thomas, it's not that big of a gap.

[typmakings]

I definitely take offer B.

[thomasscheeks]

I would pass on offer 1 but would probably jump all over offer 2, and I'm a Cooper truther. Thomas has about the same upside as Cooper and you get to trade up from 1.08 to 1.01? That's a steal

[Gtdano_14]

Offer A isn't bad, but I'd take B in a heart beat. Cooper and Amari aren't that far off in value right now, so you're giving up the 1.08 for 1.01. Even if you prefer Amari over Thomas, it's not that big of a gap.

I'm willing to bet you are correct in saying "Cooper" and "Amari" aren't that far off in value.
I'm in agreeance though, I like trade B.

[Goddard]

Offer A isn't bad, but I'd take B in a heart beat. Cooper and Amari aren't that far off in value right now, so you're giving up the 1.08 for 1.01. Even if you prefer Amari over Thomas, it's not that big of a gap.

I'm willing to bet you are correct in saying "Cooper" and "Amari" aren't that far off in value.
I'm in agreeance though, I like trade B.

Haha oops...good catch! I guess I was right though, don't see any difference in value between the two. Hopefully, people will figure out what I meant though.

[Tyrober]

Coopers upside is higher than what you'll get with Thomas but getting the 1.01 more than makes up for that. Offer 1 isnt horrible but the second one is great. Take it

[RolandsTower]

Both are overpays, take offer B before the guy sobers up.

[Generic Username]

I've had numerous callings on Cooper's value to me, to which I reply "a lot". I then get offers such as "Moncrief and 2018 2nd". For the team I own him, moving him would take a lot since it's not a contender. Offer B would have me thinking really hard if I need a RB, though I don't see it as an easy yes as others. I'm probably higher on Coop and more cautious on Thomas than most, though; but getting the 1.01 is enticing

[pierson242]

I would take B in a heartbeat
1.01 over 1.08
Thomas =Amari

[kasermap]

I value Cooper a bit ahead of Thomas mainly because the QB outlook. Plus, what happens when the coverage shifts from Cooks to Thomas now? I think it is a solid deal but think Cooper is still ahead of Thomas.

[cvbuc]

I like Thomas more than Cooper. So obviously moving up from the 1.08 to the 1.01 is gravy.

[Hambone]

B easily - Some might prefer Thomas over Cooper - to me, they are pretty even. Getting 1.1 on top is a steal

[thiagomf]

Take B and it's not even close.

[lukkynumber13]

The first is insulting, the 2nd would be a bad trade for you IMO but I could make an argument for its merit.