Trading backups

[Scorp]

Don't know whether I should offer this, but I'm wondering which side wins:
I give: McGahee & Tomlinson to the Rice/Greene owner
He gives Kevin Smith & Micheal Bush - I have Fargas FA, and Maurice Morris

Now, I'm wondering how to even out the trade with draft picks. It is a 9 round rookie/FA draft, and I don't have anything above a late 3rd round pick. He has picks in every round except for a 2010 4th round pick.

[Risky bidness]

Don't know whether I should offer this, but I'm wondering which side wins:
I give: McGahee & Tomlinson to the Rice/Greene owner
He gives Kevin Smith & Micheal Bush - I have Fargas FA, and Maurice Morris

Now, I'm wondering how to even out the trade with draft picks. It is a 9 round rookie/FA draft, and I don't have anything above a late 3rd round pick. He has picks in every round except for a 2010 4th round pick.

I'd take that trade if I was you. I'd ask for a mid rd draft pick back. My question is why do you even own Fargas? Bush has a shot to be a bellcow back if Cable means what he says. There are many including me, that think Bush is a better RB then DMC.

Kevin Smith is dead to me so I'd actually try to acauire something else from him instead.

[meineymoe]

Don't know whether I should offer this, but I'm wondering which side wins:
I give: McGahee & Tomlinson to the Rice/Greene owner
He gives Kevin Smith & Micheal Bush - I have Fargas FA, and Maurice Morris

Now, I'm wondering how to even out the trade with draft picks. It is a 9 round rookie/FA draft, and I don't have anything above a late 3rd round pick. He has picks in every round except for a 2010 4th round pick.

I think I'd call this exchange a wash. McGahee and possibly Tomlinson have better short term value, while Smith is a big question mark and Michael Bush probably has the most potential in this trade....

If anything, you might owe him a pick upgrade, but I think if this just went through with these players, that would be cool on both sides as well.

-oo-

[skip]

I wouldn't trade Kevin Smith or Michael Bush individually for the pair. Both have upside - something neither of the others offer.

[Orca]

I wouldn't trade Kevin Smith or Michael Bush individually for the pair. Both have upside - something neither of the others offer.

x2

[BradyT]

I dont care for Kevin Smith, but I´d gladly take Michael Bush, probably even without Smith for LT and McGahee.If you can get both.. nice deal!

[Misfit74]

I dont care for Kevin Smith, but I´d gladly take Michael Bush, probably even without Smith for LT and McGahee.If you can get both.. nice deal!

x2

[Steelersfan]

I wouldn't bother with Smith as I don't feel he has much of a future. McGahee and LT for Bush and a later pick would be the offer I would throw out there.