White or Adams - Poll

[ramsey8582]

Who would you rather have straight up. Both would represent my WR5.

[Phaded]

Give me Adams.

[Jjipp]

Don't overthink this. White was going in the first few picks of rookie drafts this year. His injury isn't career-altering. Would you trade 1.02 or 1.03 for Adams?

[SpartyOn]

Give me Adams.

X2.

[Needalife]

Adams by a mile for me. Rodgers vs whoever replaces Cutler next season? Easy one for my taste.

[Witchit Straws]

I didn't like White when he was healthy. Adams

[venomreapers]

I'm taking White.

Adams is a nice player, obviously has the better QB situation but I think White has the chance to be special.

[edm1990]

I'm taking White.

Adams is a nice player, obviously has the better QB situation but I think White has the chance to be special.

I agree with this. White could also be a huge let down, but he's going to have more opportunity to be that 1WR - and think his ceiling is quite a bit higher than Adams.

Adams has to fight off competition just to hold onto 3 - as I can't see him jumping Jordy or Cobb for the next 2 years or so.

[BelichekYourSelf]

White is a much better option for your team.

Neither will be starting for you. So you should go for the highest upside. White's ceiling is much higher than Adams'

Shoot for the moon and buy low on White. The fact that people would probably had laughed at you for asking this question last week should tell you that White is the better option.

[BuckeyeNation]

White is a much better option for your team.

Neither will be starting for you. So you should go for the highest upside. White's ceiling is much higher than Adams'

Shoot for the moon and buy low on White. The fact that people would probably had laughed at you for asking this question last week should tell you that White is the better option.

This. If I owned Whte, there's no way I'd consider moving him for Adams straight up. I'd sit on him until next season. The only caveat to that would be if we're later on in the season and I feel I could win a title. In that case I'd be open to moving White for a package to help put me over the top. That's a very specific scenario though and I'd have to wait until that situation arose to be able to say what I'd be willing to accept.

[bjorklunde]

White 10x over Adams. Yes, White may not play this year, but you don't need him to. Adams continues to prove that he apparently attempts to play the game wearing oven mits. The guy can't catch with his hands to save his life.

[Tiim]

White, for all of the reasons cited above: higher upside, and you can afford to wait. QB situation isn't that important IMHO - as long as it is average.

[Nightmares]

White is a much better option for your team.

Neither will be starting for you. So you should go for the highest upside. White's ceiling is much higher than Adams'

Shoot for the moon and buy low on White. The fact that people would probably had laughed at you for asking this question last week should tell you that White is the better option.

This. If I owned Whte, there's no way I'd consider moving him for Adams straight up. I'd sit on him until next season. The only caveat to that would be if we're later on in the season and I feel I could win a title. In that case I'd be open to moving White for a package to help put me over the top. That's a very specific scenario though and I'd have to wait until that situation arose to be able to say what I'd be willing to accept.

100%

[Chefrob1027]

We're judging white on one year in school and now he's likely irrelevant until next season. Adams all day here and I like white as a buy low stash but not over Adams.