WOULD YOU MAKE THIS TRADE?

[jimpal]

I have the 1.01, and am planning on taking Gordon. I have no decent RBs.
I have Green, Cobb, Matthews, Maclin, John Brown, Ellington, Richardson
Got someone who wants Green, and I think he would like to get Gordon
He has Jeremy Hill, Beckham and Julio and the 1.02
Would you trade the 1.01 and Green for the 1.02, OBJ, and Hill.

[Run and Gunner]

I would, yes.

[harr]

Big boy offer. I like it. Think its pretty fair based on current values. I personally wouldn't trade away Green and the 1.01, but I can see why someone might. Best of luck.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Yes, pretty easily. You're basically getting OBJ and Hill for Green. The 1.02 is basically the same as the 1.01 to me.

[TommyL31]

I'd make that trade. For many Gordon and Gurley are the 1a and 1b and maybe he ends up taking Gurley and you still end up with Gordon.

[maxhyde]

I have the 1.01, and am planning on taking Gordon. I have no decent RBs.
I have Green, Cobb, Matthews, Maclin, John Brown, Ellington, Richardson
Got someone who wants Green, and I think he would like to get Gordon
He has Jeremy Hill, Beckham and Julio and the 1.02
Would you trade the 1.01 and Green for the 1.02, OBJ, and Hill.

Yep. Well worth the move down a spot I think.

[FantasyFreak]

I have the 1.01, and am planning on taking Gordon. I have no decent RBs.
I have Green, Cobb, Matthews, Maclin, John Brown, Ellington, Richardson
Got someone who wants Green, and I think he would like to get Gordon
He has Jeremy Hill, Beckham and Julio and the 1.02
Would you trade the 1.01 and Green for the 1.02, OBJ, and Hill.

Yep. Well worth the move down a spot I think.

Yes, but I doubt they would accept that. I prefer Gordon to Gurley, but they are very close. AJG and Beckham are close, so he would basically be giving you Hill for nothing.

[Raftery's Onions]

Easily. I love the OBJ side by a wide margin

[dskarin]

Yup, I'd make that trade as well.

[tidewaterjc]

Yes... I would also trade AJG/1.01 for that

[Rustyram78]

I'm not sure I would. While OBJ exploded onto the scene, I'd feel more comfortable with AJG.... of course I'd like to see OBJ do this well for a full season, but, if he does, then you couldn't get him for this price.

So for me it's a risk to put this much faith in OBJ over AJH, but if you're a risk taker, go for it.

I might sleep on it and go with your gut, but in my opinion it's not a snap accept.

[Twix3474]

I would absolutely make that deal of you can pull it off.

[imi814]

I have the 1.01, and am planning on taking Gordon. I have no decent RBs.
I have Green, Cobb, Matthews, Maclin, John Brown, Ellington, Richardson
Got someone who wants Green, and I think he would like to get Gordon
He has Jeremy Hill, Beckham and Julio and the 1.02
Would you trade the 1.01 and Green for the 1.02, OBJ, and Hill.

Yep. Well worth the move down a spot I think.

Yes, but I doubt they would accept that. I prefer Gordon to Gurley, but they are very close. AJG and Beckham are close, so he would basically be giving you Hill for nothing.

I agree that there is a slim chance the other guy says yes. Obj and ajg are ver close and so is 1.01and 1.02. I doubt he thinks the difference is hill.

[Plank]

yes, I like Hill quite a bit, and if he's after Gordon, you could grab Gurley right behind him .. or if he really is after Gurley, you get Hill and Gordon as per your original plan...

[BuckeyeNation]

Pretty much OBJ/Hill for AJG. I wouldn't argue with either side. Of course the OBJ hype is so sky high that I'll probably get ridiculed for wanting AJG over OBJ. That's how I play dynasty though, it takes me a bit longer to move rookies to the top of my rankings board. It's going to take more than 12 games for me to value OBJ over AJG.

That being said, getting OBJ and Hill is pretty enticing. The pick difference in negligible to me.