Got Roasted on a Trade on DLF Forum: Who would you take post R1

[MaddMadden]

I got bullied on a forum for this trade. Using DLFs deby rankings here are top 8 in 23 (sf):

1. B. Robinson RB UT
2. B. Young QB Bama
3. CJ Stroud QB OSU
4. J. Gibbs RB Bama
5. J. Smith-Njigba WR OSU
6. K. Boutte WR LSU
7. Z. Evans RB Miss
8. J. Addison WR PITT

For context, this guy pick is 1.02 this year. I already own his pick at 1.02 and also pick 1.04. Owning 3 top 5 in this draft is puke worthy. There are only so many trades for 23 picks to go around. I acted early and got slaughtered. What say the masses now?


viewtopic.php?f=6&t=224885

[abloom]

I got bullied on a forum for this trade. Using DLFs deby rankings here are top 8 in 23 (sf):

1. B. Robinson RB UT
2. B. Young QB Bama
3. CJ Stroud QB OSU
4. J. Gibbs RB Bama
5. J. Smith-Njigba WR OSU
6. K. Boutte WR LSU
7. Z. Evans RB Miss
8. J. Addison WR PITT

For context, this guy pick is 1.02 this year. I already own his pick at 1.02 and also pick 1.04. Owning 3 top 5 in this draft is puke worthy. There are only so many trades for 23 picks to go around. I acted early and got slaughtered. What say the masses now?


viewtopic.php?f=6&t=224885

Until it's next year you won't know if it's a worthwhile trade or not. Let us know who you would have picked at 1.05 and come back next year after you draft the player in the 23 1st.

[Anteaters]

I'd rather have the '22 1.05, but it's not a terrible deal either way.

[CGW]

Fairly even. Definitely not skewed enough either way to get roasted. Of course I dont play IDP, so maybe those top few defenders are generational? Doubt it.

[CubfanAA]

I got bullied on a forum for this trade. Using DLFs deby rankings here are top 8 in 23 (sf):

1. B. Robinson RB UT
2. B. Young QB Bama
3. CJ Stroud QB OSU
4. J. Gibbs RB Bama
5. J. Smith-Njigba WR OSU
6. K. Boutte WR LSU
7. Z. Evans RB Miss
8. J. Addison WR PITT

For context, this guy pick is 1.02 this year. I already own his pick at 1.02 and also pick 1.04. Owning 3 top 5 in this draft is puke worthy. There are only so many trades for 23 picks to go around. I acted early and got slaughtered. What say the masses now?


viewtopic.php?f=6&t=224885

I would not call a 19 to 15 original vote getting bullied or slaughtered. I would say it's pretty even and depends on what happens this year. I'm always conservative on assuming draft position of future picks because anything can happen.

[dynastyninja]

"Slaughtered" is a pretty drastic overstatement of the discussion you linked. Close vote and none of the comments were outrageous.

[Jigga94]

"Slaughtered" is a pretty drastic overstatement of the discussion you linked. Close vote and none of the comments were outrageous.

This. Half of the comments in the original thread are OPs as well. And this doesn't need another thread.

OP, it's ok. You made the trade you wanted, so be happy. I'm not in love with the 1.05 spot this year and would gladly trade it for say 1.08+

If the 23 1st ends up early, that's a good deal but you have to wait a year. If it ends up late, then you waited a year for nothing probably. Time will tell

[Gator Sens]

I still would have wanted more coming back but the trade is done and just move forward. Hopefully the 2023 1st ends up early.