Stafford vs carr

[Walter Sobchak]

What side do you like
What would need.to be added to make it even

[pierson242]

Carr over Stafford! Carr is a year or two younger better weapons better team! Would need maybe a 2nd on top of Stafford

[Goddard]

Carr over Stafford! Carr is a year or two younger better weapons better team! Would need maybe a 2nd on top of Stafford

x2

[Tyrober]

Carr is 3 years younger for starters. Carr also has much better weapons and a better offense. Staffords solid and I like him but give me Carr all day. After Luck and Rodgers you could make a case for Carr being #3. He is for sure top 5 while Stafford is closer to 10. Really depends on the format to determine what would need to be added

[thomasscheeks]

Carr for me as well

[mrmagloo]

Gotta go with Carr, something about that guy. I think out of the last three years draft's, excluding last year, Winston and Carr are the guys we will be talking about in 10 years. Too early to call on Dak, like Mariota, not sure if they ever see's the level of DC and JW.

[rwstaub]

I like Stafford a lot but Carr is the higher value here. Although it looks like you have Rodgers already so if you can flip Carr into some more depth for your team, more power to you.

[colinhunt13]

Carr has a way higher upside

[Kramer]

Carr

[Parker8]

Carr = Stafford + high 2nd? Something like that.

[BuckeyeNation]

Carr = Stafford + high 2nd? Something like that.

In a vacuum that seems right, but in a 1QB format I wouldn't be willing to add a high 2nd for this type of QB upgrade. Then again owners severely devalue the QB position in most of my 1QB league, to the point where Cam can't bring in a late 1st and Luck MIGHT get a top 7-8 pick on a good day.

[nyterp]

Carr > Stafford imo. How much depends on format. I am curious if this is for your team in sig why you are trying to move Carr for another backup QB, unless they are both part of some package where you upgrade elsewhere.

[21TD]

Piling on Carr side.

[skip]

Stafford has a history of inconsistency in his play and has caused his owners great frustration. He showed better this past season without Calvin Johnson. I would never take him over Derek Carr. I would expect the difference to be a minimum of an early second round pick.

[Walter Sobchak]

Yes, its for the team in my sig
I like carr a lot more than stafford but might be able to get pick 11 for the downgrade, im hesitant because how much i like carr and i already have picks 1,2,8,14,33 so i dont think its that important.
Stafford owner has brady so he's trying to get his next starter. Im most likely keeping carr just wanted to hear opinions