Which side of this trade is better??

[pvballer3915]

Team A gets: D.Mcnabb and N.Washington

Team B gets: B.Edwards and K.Winslow


Who wins and why?

[hosler427]

Need to see the rosters to really judge that but I prefer the Edwards/Winslow side of McNabb wasn't essential

[MR ROURKE]

Edwards would never touch your starting lineup and your TE's are strong. Your backup QB's aren't good.... I'd say you lose, because I think your team woudl be worse..... but the trade is pretty fair. Cutler isn't starting this week and you are going to role with Cassel or Campbell?????

EDIT: Just noticed you have N.Washington in the trade and L.Washington in your sig, so hopefully we are discussing a different team with less QB implications on your team. Trade is even depending on the need for McNabb.

[BradyT]

Team A gets: D.Mcnabb and N.Washington

Team B gets: B.Edwards and K.Winslow


Who wins and why?

from a strict value standpoint. But everything else depends on the respective roster situations.

[Misfit74]

That's a nice haul for McNabb.

[pvballer3915]

Guys, my qbs for that leqgue are Mcnabb Vick Sanchez and Garrard. My TE is heath miller who is killing me right now. And im really weak at WR. So i had to get what i can for Mcnabb.