D Johnson for D Moncrief & J Matthews

[MacLeod]

Is this a fair trade?

Moncrief and Matthews are both on the last year of their rookie contract. They can be re-signed for $12 per year (up to 3 years) in a $104 cap league.

Johnson has 2 years left on his rookie contract and then can be re-signed for $14.25 per year.

I'm finding I am very bad at judging value for trades...I appreciate the help.

[CurtisMyFavMartin]

I have no idea about their contracts, but in a vacuum I would need a 1st on top of Moncreif and Matthews for my DJ to even open up talks.

[harr]

I'd rather have DJ.

[mullmania]

DJ might be the #1 player in fantasy right now.

Hold

[smmcfarl]

If this is for the team in your sig and you're getting DJ absolutely do that trade if you can get it.

[Concept Coop]

DJ.

[0crush83]

Is this a fair trade?

Moncrief and Matthews are both on the last year of their rookie contract. They can be re-signed for $12 per year (up to 3 years) in a $104 cap league.

Johnson has 2 years left on his rookie contract and then can be re-signed for $14.25 per year.

I'm finding I am very bad at judging value for trades...I appreciate the help.

Was this trade offered to you? If so take it! If you are planning on offering this, expect it to get rejected.

[MacLeod]

Is this a fair trade?

Moncrief and Matthews are both on the last year of their rookie contract. They can be re-signed for $12 per year (up to 3 years) in a $104 cap league.

Johnson has 2 years left on his rookie contract and then can be re-signed for $14.25 per year.

I'm finding I am very bad at judging value for trades...I appreciate the help.

Was this trade offered to you? If so take it! If you are planning on offering this, expect it to get rejected.

I'm really trying to find out what I would need to offer to make it a fair deal. October ADP has Johnson 8th, Moncrief 25th, and Matthews 28th. FantasyPros' dynasty rankings has Johnson at 10, Moncrief at 22, and Matthews at 29.

I am trying to figure out how that all translates when it comes to making a deal. I'm not good at that sort of thing. =(

Thanks for all the replies so far.

It is the team in my sig...if you were me, where would you start? Or would it even be worth it? Thanks!

[hord]

i dont think your close to be honest... october rankings aside... i think dj is 3rd at worst behind maybe bell and brown... and id personally rather have dj over bell.... dj has his head on straight and i think will be more reliable.
i own all three of those players that you are talking about... and id give up moncrief and matthews long before i moved dj..

[Coogan Football]

Offer Ajayi +JMatt and see what he/she says

[moishetreats]

DJ is the best player. And, if I read your post correctly, he can end up being kept for the longest time. He's the choice here -- by far. To make this work, you'd need to offer players who are cheaper and who could be kept for as long as if not longer than DJ.