Geno Atkins trade

[SteelerFan4Life]

Would you do this deal:
Give - Atkins
Get - Kyle Williams, 2.7 and 2015 2nd (probably be 5-7 range)

Starting Req - 1 DT, 2 DE, 2 LB, 2 DB
DT Scoring is 2 pts for T, 1.25 for AT, 4 pts for Sack, 2 pts for tackle for loss..

Current Defensive Roster is:
DT - Atkins,Chris Jones, K Langford
DE - JJ Watt, Pitoitua, Wootton, Carradine
LB - Kuechly, Riley, D Davis, Jarvis Jones, Te'o
DB - P Peterson, Newman, Ihedigbo

I'd probably be hoping to get one of CJ Mosley, Borland or Van Noy at the 2.7... seeing how I am pretty sure that Clowney, Mack and Barr will be long gone.

[Team Tacos]

I'd try to get more than that for Atkins. I mean, it's not a bad deal, but Atkins is in a DT tier of his own. If one of those 2nds could turn into a 1st you'd have an auto-accept on your hands.

[will6779]

I would accept that for atkins.

[SteelerFan4Life]

Ya... I think its good value.. just not sure if I want to lose him or not.. getting Williams helps for a couple years.. IF he can repeat last years success.. which I am not sure he can... I think I can get something decent on the defensive side at the 2.7

[rangerdave]

It's fair value, but as you have to start a DT, I would look to get more back for a guy likely to be top five at the position for a number of years.