Mixon - Sanders swap

[Doodootime]

I’m looking at giving Sanders and getting Mixon in return. I make regular playoff appearances but have yet to make it to the last game. How do you feel about mixon and sanders over my next 2-3 year window?

[Gator Sens]

Mixon for me. He has the much better chance at being a true workhorse in my opinion. Volume is so important for RBs in fantasy.

[never_punts]

Mixon is slightly, slightly > Sanders to me. He's a workhorse and that offense absolutely has nowhere to go but up. He's a super talent and his breakout is coming.

[BradysBunch]

I have been high on both. Pretty close for me, so I would take the younger one. If Philly used a descent draft pick on a RB, this would not be close. But since I think they will get close to the same amount of touches, I will take Sanders. At the same time though... trading...if I had mixon and know the majority perception of these two, I would want something else coming back to me.

[Dynasty19]

It’s close. Mixon has more curb appeal to me. Interested in seeing a poll on this.

[eraldo_coil]

Not really a fan of lateral moves like this. I guess Mixon is technically considered slightly more valuable right now, but it feels negligible enough that a straight across trade like this doesn’t really make sense to me. I am really high on both players so this feels like a “pick em” in my eyes.

[HughHoney]

Mixon but very close

[MFundercover]

Sanders. The Eagles have done everything to indicate he will going to be a major contributor to the offense going forward for the past year. Not even sure why some people still argue rbbc and we wont get enough touches to be elite.

[FantasyFreak]

Mixon is a legit Bell Cow. Like me some Sanders, but still hasn't shown to be a good runner between the tackles. Mixon should get more touches and he should produce more with a better QB. Hold out is the the potential downside, but Mixon is the more talented back with a line to more touches.

[FantasyFreak]

Mixon for me. He has the much better chance at being a true workhorse in my opinion. Volume is so important for RBs in fantasy.

Agreed. As I stated earlier, the real concern is him holding out. Mixon is bigger, better and in a more prominent role in the system. If he holds out, it might be a hiccup, but the new CBA suggests he has little leverage.

[Zacsby]

I guess I'd rather have Mixon, but I don't see how this significantly changes your outlook. You probably should be shopping Juju or DJM for a RB if thats what you need to get over the hump. Is this a start 3 RB league? Not sure cause you currently have Hunt highlighted over both of those WRs.

[punintended]

Mixon by a good amount for me.

I’d need an early first to go from Mixon to Sanders.

[joeday]

Give me Sanders. When players are absolutely horrendous for half of a season and potentially ruin fantasy teams then they leave a sour taste in my mouth.