Trade for MHJ?

[CGW]

12tm SF PPR (6pt passing TD)
QB RB RB WR WR WR TE SF FL FL
Murray, Purdy, Young
Miller, Charbs
Wilson, Olave, Waddle, Flowers, M Wilson, Mingo
Kincaid, Hockenson, Chig
1.01, 1.11, 3.01, 3.05, 4.01, 4.05
2025 | 3x 1st, 2x 2nd

Was offered a deal for Murray, but countered with this. Was declined, said he needs something other than Hock. Would you add a WR or 2025 1st to the deal instead of Hock to make it happen or just forget it?

His offer (countered):
Give: Murray, 1.11
Get: 1.05, 1.06, 2.11

My counter (declined):
Give: Murray, Hockenson, 1.11
Get: 1.02, 1.05

[CGW]

Also, for context...this is a year two league where I ignored the RB position with the goal to punt to 2025. Next year I have three of this years non playoff teams firsts, so hopefully can pick up some good RBs then and be ready to go. I like the idea of adding Caleb and MHJ, plus Nabers, Odunze or Daniels at 1.05 if I can get this deal done.

[Menace2010]

I wouldn't add any of your top 4 WRs, but could see adding a lesser WR or swapping Hockenson with a future (ideally late) 1st. With 1.01 in the fold I'd be more comfortable with this deal. Was initially out, since you'd be left with no QB1.

[TheTroll]

Ewe. Pass on the counter

[CGW]

Ewe. Pass on the counter

That was my counter, not his lol. This is how me and this guy do it. He sends me a low-ball, I send him one back. Then we start the real discussion, which is where my question comes in - what should I offer, if anything

[dblj1199]

I guess a bit of this comes down to his roster and what he has at qb / te. You'd land the top two players with Caleb / MHJ and be stacked at wr. I think it's a fair deal if he's high on Kyler and needs a qb that has shown he can play at times. Good luck.
Also if you make this deal I'd put 1.5 on the block and look to add a rb.