1QB League - Trade Advice (Eitienne, Hock)

[Nflnz]

For the team below, I will need to trim my roster (league also has 6IDP spots not shown) and wonder if this is a trade worth making.

Give: Hock (or Kelce) & Etienne
Get: Tank & 2025 1st

I think the 2025 1st may be early as the other team has the below roster. Obviously getting Etienne will help him, and he’ll go Nabers at 1.02 but it’s not a championship team.

QB: Love, Tua
RB: Jacob’s, Kamara, Elliot, Ford
WR: Metcalf, Dell, Meyers, Cooks, Palmer, Lazard
TE: Waller, Jonu
Picks: 1.02 (Nabers), 2.02, 3.02, 4.02, 5.05




Team1
12 Team 1QB, 2RB, 3WR, 1TE, 1Flex R/W/T
QB: Dak, Stafford, Tannehill, Levis
RB: Taylor, Mixon, Etienne, Hall, White
WR: Chase, Lamb, Puka, M Williams, JSN, Juju, R Moore
TE: Kelce, Hock, Mcbride
2024 1.10, 2.03, 2.10, 4.10, 5.10

[tstafford]

Sending him Hock will help him less in '24 so that's good re: the pick. It's also sort of weird that he's offering this deal. I don't see how it helps his team. But that's neither here nor there.

Overall: I don't think you're getting enough back. While I prefer Tank to ETN, ETN carries more value. And either of those TEs is worth at least a first. This is being 1QB, I'd ask for his 2.02 on top of the current offer.

Note: I don't want to justify the trade on the assumption that the 2025 1st is early. I see it as fairly random.

[TheTroll]

Sending him Hock will help him less in '24 so that's good re: the pick. It's also sort of weird that he's offering this deal. I don't see how it helps his team. But that's neither here nor there.

Overall: I don't think you're getting enough back. While I prefer Tank to ETN, ETN carries more value. And either of those TEs is worth at least a first. This is being 1QB, I'd ask for his 2.02 on top of the current offer.

Note: I don't want to justify the trade on the assumption that the 2025 1st is early. I see it as fairly random.

I like the Hock for a better chance for 2025 draft slot

[The.Big.Spank]

Sending him Hock will help him less in '24 so that's good re: the pick. It's also sort of weird that he's offering this deal. I don't see how it helps his team. But that's neither here nor there.

Overall: I don't think you're getting enough back. While I prefer Tank to ETN, ETN carries more value. And either of those TEs is worth at least a first. This is being 1QB, I'd ask for his 2.02 on top of the current offer.

Note: I don't want to justify the trade on the assumption that the 2025 1st is early. I see it as fairly random.

This

[Ryantacular]

Hock + ETN easily. (Also like Hock + ETN more than Kelce + ETN at this point for dynasty).

I would not give hock or ETN 1 for 1 for Tank. I also would not give either 1 for 1 for 2025 first. (might do Kelce for 2025 1st + a little sprinles).

[Viking386]

Hock + ETN easily. (Also like Hock + ETN more than Kelce + ETN at this point for dynasty).

I would not give hock or ETN 1 for 1 for Tank. I also would not give either 1 for 1 for 2025 first. (might do Kelce for 2025 1st + a little sprinles).

This. You are losing too much value on the Hock and ETN trade. Selling Hock now would be such a loss of value. Once he returns thats the time to sell him to a contending team. Kelce for a 25 1st makes more sense.