Interesting offer - send my 1st?

[Prison_Mike]

12tm PPR SF - I did a Year 1 punt/productive struggle.

So my pick is currently the 1.02. I recently acquired Mahomes

Normally, I wouldn't even consider giving up my pick in a year when I've done YR1P, but the value feels pretty good here. Not to mention, if I make this trade, it will almost certainly take my pick from early to mid '24 1st

Give: '24 1st + '24 2nd + Spears + Roschon
Get: Breece + London + Swift + Levis

Here's my team:
Start: 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 2FLX, 1SF
QB: Mahomes, Kyler, Wentz
RB: Taylor, Javonte, Warren, Ford, Spears, RJ, K.Herbert
WR: G.Wilson, JSN, Diontae, Doubs, Douglas
TE: Pitts, McBride, Woods, Dulcich
'24 picks: (x3) 1sts (1 early, 1 mid, 1 late), (x1) early 2nd

Thoughts?

[abloom]

Who's the second London?

If you aren't competing I see no reason to make the deal, it will likely still be there in the future.

[mikedigs]

Would rather keep the 1.02 and 2.02 and go for MHJ. Spears and Roschon trending up and fit the rebuild. Breece is a stud but so is MHJ and should be the more valuable asset.

[Prison_Mike]

Who's the second London?

I'm an idiot

It's Levis

[abloom]

Who's the second London?

I'm an idiot

It's Levis

Still a pass for me

[mikedigs]

Who's the second London?

I'm an idiot

It's Levis

Still a pass for me

x2. Gotta go MHJ with the 1.02.

[Prison_Mike]

Would rather keep the 1.02 and 2.02 and go for MHJ. Spears and Roschon trending up and fit the rebuild. Breece is a stud but so is MHJ and should be the more valuable asset.

Thanks guys. What do you think of a counter of the mid 1st instead of early 1st?

If that doesn't work, what about a counter of sending both of the later 1sts and keeping my early 1st and 2nd? So it would be:

Give: 1.06 + 1.12 + Spears + RJ
Get: Hall + London + Swift + Levis

Would keep 1.02 and 2.02

(using current pick values, they'll obviously fluctuate. But the 1.06 is a contender who's top-3 in Max Points. 1.12 team is undefeated)

[mikedigs]

Would rather keep the 1.02 and 2.02 and go for MHJ. Spears and Roschon trending up and fit the rebuild. Breece is a stud but so is MHJ and should be the more valuable asset.

Thanks guys. What do you think of a counter of the mid 1st instead of early 1st?

If that doesn't work, what about a counter of sending both of the later 1sts and keeping my early 1st and 2nd? So it would be:

Give: 1.06 + 1.12 + Spears + RJ
Get: Hall + London + Swift + Levis

Would keep 1.02 and 2.02

(using current pick values, they'll obviously fluctuate. But the 1.06 is a contender who's top-3 in Max Points. 1.12 team is undefeated)

I def like that offer alot better. I was never too high on London, but he's a solid young WR. Levis a solid add, and Hall is a stud. If you can pull that one off I dig it.

[Gator Sens]

Would rather keep the 1.02 and 2.02 and go for MHJ. Spears and Roschon trending up and fit the rebuild. Breece is a stud but so is MHJ and should be the more valuable asset.

Thanks guys. What do you think of a counter of the mid 1st instead of early 1st?

If that doesn't work, what about a counter of sending both of the later 1sts and keeping my early 1st and 2nd? So it would be:

Give: 1.06 + 1.12 + Spears + RJ
Get: Hall + London + Swift + Levis

Would keep 1.02 and 2.02

(using current pick values, they'll obviously fluctuate. But the 1.06 is a contender who's top-3 in Max Points. 1.12 team is undefeated)

This is a much better option for you if this is on the table. This deal allows you to stay in the Williams/Harrison Jr. sweepstakes and Hall is worth more long term than both of the picks arguably. While London has a ways to go, getting London and Swift for essentially Spears + Johnson is really nice value.

[Dibbles]

This deal is a no brainer if you can pull it off.

Give: 1.06 + 1.12 + Spears + RJ
Get: Hall + London + Swift + Levis

[Weber27]

I would try and remove swift from the deal and keep RJ or Spears and that would help bridge the gap from 1.02 to 1.06. I don’t like adding swift to a rebuild and I’d rather keep the up and coming RB.

[CGW]

Like your counter idea. If you can land Breece, London, Swift, and Levis while keeping your 1.02 I'd say you aren't in a rebuild anymore.

I'd be willing to give up both your later 1sts, Spears, Roschon, and the 2nd to get that done.

[Prison_Mike]

Got it done, thanks all.

[TheTroll]

Got it done, thanks all.

Excellent for you. Good job