2019 Bad Trade Offers

[ravn88]

Super flex, 2 TE +1.0 ppr

I get:

James White, Damien Williams, Auden Tate, Deebo Samuel, 2020 2nd round, 2020 4th round

for

Darnold, Engram, R. Anderson and Diontae Johnson

Seems fair..

[PTW32]

Give: Michael Thomas + 3rd
Get: Terry McLaurin + 2nd

[Prison_Mike]

Here we go again with this league (team 3)

In need of a QB - (Start 1QB league)

I sent this offer which I felt was very fair, possibly even an overpay

Give: Jimmy G + Royce + 2020 2nd (early/mid)
Get: Josh Allen (QB2 on his bench)

He rejected and countered with:

I give: Hunter Henry + 2020 1st (top-3 lock)
I get: 12-inch Minsh (QB4 on his bench)

[djeternal2]

Give: Michael Thomas + 3rd
Get: Terry McLaurin + 2nd

McLaurin's 2 years younger and you upgrade your 3rd to a 2nd. Have you not watched McLaurin ball out this year? This is a steal!

[smoger45]

I give Zach Ertz and early 2nd

Get McKinnon and late 1st

[PTW32]

Give: Michael Thomas + 3rd
Get: Terry McLaurin + 2nd

McLaurin's 2 years younger and you upgrade your 3rd to a 2nd. Have you not watched McLaurin ball out this year? This is a steal!

I guess i didnt think about it that way. I'll go back and accept. Thanks

[hoos89]

Here we go again with this league (team 3)

In need of a QB - (Start 1QB league)

I sent this offer which I felt was very fair, possibly even an overpay

Give: Jimmy G + Royce + 2020 2nd (early/mid)
Get: Josh Allen (QB2 on his bench)

He rejected and countered with:

I give: Hunter Henry + 2020 1st (top-3 lock)
I get: 12-inch Minsh (QB4 on his bench)

No price is too great for Minshew.

[Prison_Mike]

Here we go again with this league (team 3)

In need of a QB - (Start 1QB league)

I sent this offer which I felt was very fair, possibly even an overpay

Give: Jimmy G + Royce + 2020 2nd (early/mid)
Get: Josh Allen (QB2 on his bench)

He rejected and countered with:

I give: Hunter Henry + 2020 1st (top-3 lock)
I get: 12-inch Minsh (QB4 on his bench)

No price is too great for Minshew.

Apparently

[bjd5211]

This certainly is not the worst on this thread value wise (although I still think it's not great), but it's the type of bad offer that really annoys me the most because there is clearly zero thought given into what might actually fit the needs or plans of your trade partner.

Offer was

I give: Gallup

I receive: Jimmy Graham

This is a 12 team PPR league, no TE Premium, start 3 WR and 1 TE with 1 flex (RB/WR/TE)

I'm a very young team and still rebuilding, but have Hunter Henry, Noah Fant and Dallas Goedert at TE already. WR however I'm rather thin, DJ Chark, Gallup, MVS, Preston Williams, Trequan Smith and N'Keal Harry (IR). So what exactly would be the reasoning this offer would remotely interest me?

[Mephistopheles]

McCoy fumbles, gets in the doghouse and benched.
So it must be perfectly logical that I would want to:

Give: David Johnson
Get: LeSean McCoy.

SMH. How do these idiots dress themselves in the morning?

ETA: the follow up on this was hilarious. He asked what I would want for DJ, I responded his 2020 and 2021 1sts (both likely late). He responded "Is this still 2016 or is DJ a banged up 30 year old back?".
My response was "If it were 2016, McCoy wouldn't be a 32 year old back demoted to third string for fumbling. And FYI, DJ is 27 not 30. Lying to gain position in a trade will get you exactly nowhere. My price is now 3 1sts, take it or leave me alone".

[badbuddah]

McCoy fumbles, gets in the doghouse and benched.
So it must be perfectly logical that I would want to:

Give: David Johnson
Get: LeSean McCoy.

SMH. How do these idiots dress themselves in the morning?

ETA: the follow up on this was hilarious. He asked what I would want for DJ, I responded his 2020 and 2021 1sts (both likely late). He responded "Is this still 2016 or is DJ a banged up 30 year old back?".
My response was "If it were 2016, McCoy wouldn't be a 32 year old back demoted to third string for fumbling. And FYI, DJ is 27 not 30. Lying to gain position in a trade will get you exactly nowhere. My price is now 3 1sts, take it or leave me alone".

[themburns]

Give: Cooper Kupp
Receive: 2020 1st (currently 1.13), Lamar Miller, Phillip Dorsett

[trc]

Here we go again with this league (team 3)

In need of a QB - (Start 1QB league)

I sent this offer which I felt was very fair, possibly even an overpay

Give: Jimmy G + Royce + 2020 2nd (early/mid)
Get: Josh Allen (QB2 on his bench)

He rejected and countered with:

I give: Hunter Henry + 2020 1st (top-3 lock)
I get: 12-inch Minsh (QB4 on his bench)

No price is too great for Minshew.

Apparently

Lol, that 2nd should have been enough..

[Prison_Mike]

No price is too great for Minshew.

Apparently

Lol, that 2nd should have been enough..

lol for sure
I know my league & I know an overpay is required to get a deal done, which is why I was willing to do it

But that counter is just outrageous lol

[TheNuts]

14 team ppr. Tight end gets 75% reception bonus

I give Evan Engram, Dwayne Washington, Taywan Taylor

I get: Rashad Penny, Foster Moreau, Mark Walton

Penny could get traded, Walton is now a starter, and Moreau is a very important handcuff to my Waller.