Sammy Watkins for Joe mixon?

[dblj1199]

I think I'm with everyone, Mixon easily here. Sammy has shown flashes and that is it. He has a injury history and didn't even have his 5th year option picked up before being traded away. I'll take the upside of Mixon all day long, they can improve the o-line in the offseason and it can make for a whole new Mixon.

[Ghosted]

Mixon by an early 2nd for me, which hurts my soul to say.

[cptjonesb]

I guess it's "fair" value, but I'd take Mixon over Sammy pretty easily.

This is how I see it also

[Trevormortis]

Mixon for me.

[Slackalacker]

You'll probably have to add to Sammy to get Mixon at this point.

[dipANDglide]

As a Sammy owner I think I'm in for the long haul. He passes the eye test when healthy and getting targets, problem is neither are ever happening together. Mixon isn't a bad piece for Sammy at all. Tough choice .Goodluck

x2

x3. Stay healthy and get somewhere where they'll feed you, Sammy!!!!

[1957notthatlongago]

I made a similar trade this year: traded Watkins and Perine for Mixon and Benjamin. This was the day after Sammy blew up on national tv. Yes, this is me boasting

[joedirte]

As someone who owns both, I still value Sammy more. I still believe in the talent and think now is an awful time to sell.

[jimmy jr.]

I own both in my main league , I would have to take Mixon. , but it would take a lot to get Sammy from me also.

[BradysBunch]

As a mixon owner, I would need to be convinced that a first would be at least a mid Rd pick. Then I would consider a first with Watkins.

[Tennisbuck]

Just to pile it on I would take Mixon! I had Sammy and unloaded him a few weeks ago.