Make the trade proposal or not?

[Humble]

I'm considering to propose the following trade to another owner in my dynasty league:

My trade package: J. Matt, S. Diggs, I. Crowell, Duke Johnson and 2017 3rd round pick

for: S. Watkins and J. Hill or S. Watkins and E. Lacy.

12 team PPR
MY Team
QB: A. Rodgers and. Bridgewater
RBS: DJ, Ellington, M. Gordon, I. Crowell, Duke Johnson and Smallwood
WRS: Moncrief R. Cobb, J Matt, D. Adams, Crowder, Perriman , S. Diggs, Treadwell, P. Dorsett and Caroo.

Thank you for your advice.

[Spartan]

Watkins is worth more than the package so adding a RB on top of that is crazy imo. The person giving Watkins would also need to drop an extra 2 players from his roster which makes the deal even more lopsided (4 quarters for a dollar is usually never a good deal).

[People Mover]

Anyone else have an opinion?

[SpartacusPTech]

I'm considering to propose the following trade to another owner in my dynasty league:

My trade package: J. Matt, S. Diggs, I. Crowell, Duke Johnson and 2017 3rd round pick

for: S. Watkins and J. Hill or S. Watkins and E. Lacy.

12 team PPR
MY Team
QB: A. Rodgers and. Bridgewater
RBS: DJ, Ellington, M. Gordon, I. Crowell, Duke Johnson and Smallwood
WRS: Moncrief R. Cobb, J Matt, D. Adams, Crowder, Perriman , S. Diggs, Treadwell, P. Dorsett and Caroo.

Thank you for your advice.

I don't think that gets it done. There might be an outside shot that the Sammy/Hill one could work if he is really down on Hill.
But worth a shot I guess. I think you'd have to at least change that 3rd to a 1st for it to really be considered.

[jonny]

Watkins is worth more than the package...

^^

[sloth8u]

In a competitive league, that doesn't get it done most times. This may work for you.... if so, great.

Honestly, it just looks bad. A bunch of meh and jmatt for sammy. Get rid of everything....offer jmatt. Diggs, and duke for sammy. As you have it now.... you'd like to offer jmatt for sammy, then clev backfield for lacy...and your adding your 3rd. Not a good offer.

[People Mover]

Thanks for the feedback.

[jpusmc0311]

I'm high on JMatt, but I still don't think this gets done.. Like the guy said above, you would have to change the 3rd pick to a 1st, and that would make it closer.

[The.Big.Spank]

I would keep my sammy and reject this trade.

[People Mover]

Thanks.