Mike Evans or Keenan Allen

[Prickler]

Who would you rather have in a 12team PPR startup?

[Overachiever77]

Mike Evans, younger, bigger, and potential TD monster.

[KMA]

I own Keenan but feel Mike Evans has the slight edge with a young Winston growing with him.

[Steelersfan]

Evans, he's the more prototypical WR1 imo.

[murphysxm]

I love Keenan Allen and expect a massive break out. I think Mike Evans is massively overrated. That being said, I think Evans is probably the better pick here

[Big Al]

Piling on with Evans

[Gaoh-X]

Evans has a huge celling, is 22
Allen showed that he can be a monster in PPR
I'll take the upside with a young stud QB, Evans for me

[Crwdstunna]

Evans has more upside to be a sustainable WR1 imo

[GridironGuerilla]

More of the same. Evans for me.

[DYNASTY BALLA$]

Evans over Keenan for a few reason. First off, Evans has a major size advantage which will make him a constant red zone threat. Another reason is Rivers will be 35 by season's end and that limits Keenan's future upside, whereas Evans has the opportunity (and ability) to become one of the top WR's for the next 10 years with Winston and him both only being 22 years old.

[sportsjunky1422]

I like em both but give me Evans over Allen

[Prospector]

Evans because of his TD potential. They are both going to get peppered with targets and Keenan may even end up with more catches but Keenan never seems to rack up TDs in large amounts. I think Evans gets double digit TDs this year and shows positive TD regression! Really - both are fantastic.

[Dase]

Evans

[Valhalla]

I'm assuming the 20% Keenan vote is the "I own Keenan and I need to do what I can to boost his value" vote.

[captain caveman]

I don't own Allen but I think he is the better pure PPR wr. 35 year old Rivers isn't as bad as people think. With the kind of fire in his belly I'd say he is good for another 4 years....maybe 5 so Allen will be just fine.