Dynasty League Football Forum

Who is the better wr?

voted Williams, but I'd take just about anyone over Harvin. I've never been high on the guy.

Neither are great.

Williams I guess.

Williams. Harvin has teased us long enough and Romo >>> any Bills QB.

I'd take Percy, though neither would be targets. I've seen Percy ball though, at least I know he's got it in him somewhere. I feel like the only reason we know T. Williams name is he caught a few flukey TDs his rookie season, artificially boosting his numbers.

Steelersfan wrote:Williams. Harvin has teased us long enough and Romo >>> any Bills QB.

X2. Although Williams is a boom or bust player, he still has room to grow, he ran a limited route tree at Baylor. He was also hurt the last month or so of the season and played through it, he ended up with only like 600 yards but 8 TDs and 3 more in the playoffs. I don't want anything to do with any WR in the Bills passing game not named Watkins.

TWill for me. I've seen enough of Harvin to be officially done with him, plus his situation is pretty terrible. I'm not terribly high on Williams but I'd rather gamble on him progressing in year 3.

Harvin is a pure roster clogger, whereas TWill actually offers at least bye-week flex value. Give me Williams.

Harvin is a perpetual disappointment

sugbear65 wrote:I'd take Percy, though neither would be targets. I've seen Percy ball though, at least I know he's got it in him somewhere. I feel like the only reason we know T. Williams name is he caught a few flukey TDs his rookie season, artificially boosting his numbers.

This. Williams isn't even the WR2 on his own team.

I'll take Williams. He'll probably be healthy when you need him and could possibly get in the end zone. Harvin won't be healthy. Or useful.

TW
He's not consistent but a good plug in. Harvin is a headache.

sugbear65 wrote:I'd take Percy, though neither would be targets. I've seen Percy ball though, at least I know he's got it in him somewhere. I feel like the only reason we know T. Williams name is he caught a few flukey TDs his rookie season, artificially boosting his numbers.

No offense but if you watch Cowboys games, you would see that TWill is getting single covered on basically every play, there's nothing flukey about his touchdowns. He has over 1,300 yards and 13 touchdowns in his first 2 seasons as a pro and had another 3 in the playoffs last season. He ran a limited route tree at Baylor and from my understanding, he still is learning to run routes better which is one of the reasons Romo doesn't go to him all of the time and in that offense, there are so many weapons, it's hard to feed everyone and he also played hurt the last month or so but still managed to catch 3 very important touchdowns in the playoffs. As far as fantasy, he's not my favorite player to own, I only have him on one team because he disappears in games for the reasons I mentioned but he's a good football player, nothing flukey about his game. Again I'm not trying to be a d***k but I just strongly disagree with the flukey comments.

Flip a coin. Neither is a guy I would actively pursue or who would make a difference to me in adding to a trade. If I had to pick I would probably take Williams because he's a year younger and has size and speed.