2QB league: Ryan vs Wilson

[breeze]

6 point pass TD. 10 team league. I have Brees, Stafford, Ryan and Mettenberger.

Edit: Flip Ryan for Russell Wilson?

[Sliup]

I own Ryan in a 2QB league and would need a lot added to Tannehill even to consider that swap

[breeze]

I own Ryan in a 2QB league and would need a lot added to Tannehill even to consider that swap

That's how I feel. I need a QB2 this week because 3 of my guys are on byes and every week is vital right now but this just doesn't make sense

[PPE82]

A first and a nice prospect would get me thinking...especially since u have brees/stafford already

[voiceofunreason]

6 point pass TD. 10 team league. I have Brees, Stafford, Ryan and Mettenberger.

What would need to be added to Tannehill to make it a fair trade for Ryan? Picks or WR2/RB2 etc.

Wouldn't even think of it, just a real bad idea. Tannehill looks closer to being a bust then turning the corner. Starting to look like his ceiling is Alex Smith I hate to say. Don't overreact to some o-line problems for Atlanta.

[breeze]

Change of plans. Once I thought about it I decided against Tannehill. However I may be able to do a straight swap of Ryan for Wilson. These two are pretty much a coin flip right? I'm thinking since I already have Brees/Stafford that Wilson almost is a better option for me because he is 3 years younger than Ryan and Brees won't last forever. Thoughts?

[Phaded]

I have both of them on the team in my sig.
'
They're about equal in my opinion.

Can't hurt that much to flip them. Wilson may be limited by the passing attempts, but that could change in the coming years. On top of that - Wilson gets the rushing yards.

I think if I had to choose - I would choose Wilson.