DMC vs. Spiller

[Krang]

Thoughts on this one? I know McFadden's injury history is likely to skew the answers in Spiller's favor, but how close is it from a production standpoint? When both are healthy they actually strike me as very similar players, and they are nearly identical in age.

[Team Tacos]

i love them both, and think that comparisons between them are interesting. it seems like spiller is getting all the love right now and deservedly so, especially after the greg knapp experiment in oakland last year. spiller has less miles on him so there's that, but darren is taller and bigger. i still think mcfadden can pull it together and consistently do big things. i might be the last one, but i believe in darren. he's a good buy low i think. it might be better to compare spiller with jamaal charles.

[MR ROURKE]

I'd take either on my team, but I'd favor Spiller if I had to choose.

[zjdlmt]

I just traded for McFadden yesterday and pointed out that he's actually three weeks younger than Spiller. My league got riled up that I would dare to compare the two as the consensus there is that Spiller is way more talented. I think it's interesting that McFadden is younger and they both have a relatively small number of career touches but there's a sense that Spiller is on the cusp of his career taking off while McFadden is old news.