Rice or James Cook (poll)

[Hankybro21]

Team 2. 10tm SF

Start: Q1 R2 W3 T1 F2 SF1


Give: Cook; Get: Rice

I really don’t envision having to rely on cook this year (hopefully not, anyway) so this would be a move for next year considering whatever is going on with rice at the moment.

Thoughts? Hold Cook just in case? Or take a stab that Rice figures it out and is a solid WR2

FWIW, I have three 2025 firsts, two of which should be early and likely used on RBs

[Dusticlez1]

I would hold Cook, and maybe try for someone else if you really wanna trade him. Rice is kinda in limbo and will get a suspension at some point this year or next…Rice is also one bone headed mistake away from being in the eternal dog house. I’d want a 2nd added to Rice to offset the risk if I was gonna make this move.

Maybe target someone else around the same ADP, I’d guess Reed is near there…maybe Tee, some seem to be out on him…

Also, I’d expect a decent season out of Cook this season, as much as I hate to admit, can’t stand the Bills…

[NathanielWegman]

I would hold Cook, and maybe try for someone else if you really wanna trade him. Rice is kinda in limbo and will get a suspension at some point this year or next…Rice is also one bone headed mistake away from being in the eternal dog house. I’d want a 2nd added to Rice to offset the risk if I was gonna make this move.

Maybe target someone else around the same ADP, I’d guess Reed is near there…maybe Tee, some seem to be out on him…

Also, I’d expect a decent season out of Cook this season, as much as I hate to admit, can’t stand the Bills…

Agreed

[moishetreats]

From a value perspective, Rice and not close -- especially if you're not really looking at this year.

Given the fickle nature of RBs, I don't think Rice is at any more risk of having his value tank than Cook. And he has faaaaaar more capacity for a value rebound.

[TheTroll]

I would hold Cook, and maybe try for someone else if you really wanna trade him. Rice is kinda in limbo and will get a suspension at some point this year or next…Rice is also one bone headed mistake away from being in the eternal dog house. I’d want a 2nd added to Rice to offset the risk if I was gonna make this move.

Maybe target someone else around the same ADP, I’d guess Reed is near there…maybe Tee, some seem to be out on him…

Also, I’d expect a decent season out of Cook this season, as much as I hate to admit, can’t stand the Bills…

Agreed

X2