Nix or Fields +

[saw061600]

Who would you rather?
Nix
Fields 3.06 25 third

[TheTroll]

Fields + for me. I know peeps are down on him right now but he will electrify once “Cooked Russ” is done. He’s a FF asset while on the field.

[frerichs5]

Nix. Not close for me. Yes, Fields is great for fantasy if he’s playing, but I have no confidence he is ever playing meaningful snaps again outside of injury to a starter.

[Menace2010]

I'll take the starting QB over a backup QB.

[blemly]

Can I commander this to ask what Fields’ dynasty value is? Mid 2nd too much? I kind of prefer a late 2nd but curious what others think.

[Black Adam]

Nix, and it's not even close.


To all the truthers ITT: I wonder how many rookie QBs didn't even make it out of their first contract, got traded for pennies on the dollar, and went on to start for another team and play at a high level?

Serious question, because I can't think of any "busts" in recent memory that later shook that label off as a QB, except for maybe Goff and A. Smith.

[Black Adam]

Can I commander this to ask what Fields’ dynasty value is? Mid 2nd too much? I kind of prefer a late 2nd but curious what others think.

1 QB: Late 2024 2nd (12 tm).
SF/2: Late 1st (1.12) (12 tm).

[CGW]

At this point I dont know how it's not Nix. Fields isn't even a starting QB. Reset with Nix.

[TheTroll]

Yep I get I’m going to be alone here. Nix has the safer floor immediately. I’m looking higher ceiling. I’m totally ok to be on an island with this one.

[Buckhill Bombers]

I see why people are saying Nix...but is everyone really that confident old man Wilson keeps Fields on the bench all year? I have my doubts...I could see taking Fields and the future pick personally...

[frerichs5]

Can I commander this to ask what Fields’ dynasty value is? Mid 2nd too much? I kind of prefer a late 2nd but curious what others think.

1 QB: Late 2024 2nd (12 tm).
SF/2: Late 1st (1.12) (12 tm).

I disagree with this. I wouldn’t give that for him in either format. I’d struggle to give more than a 3rd in SF and likely wouldn’t give anything in 1 QB.

Your previous post you said it was Nix and not close. 1.12 is right in line with Nix’s ADP.

[Black Adam]

Can I commander this to ask what Fields’ dynasty value is? Mid 2nd too much? I kind of prefer a late 2nd but curious what others think.

1 QB: Late 2024 2nd (12 tm).
SF/2: Late 1st (1.12) (12 tm).

I disagree with this. I wouldn’t give that for him in either format. I’d struggle to give more than a 3rd in SF and likely wouldn’t give anything in 1 QB.

Your previous post you said it was Nix and not close. 1.12 is right in line with Nix’s ADP.

Hey mane, I never said I'd give that for Fields, that's what his dyno value is according to the charts I use.

I don't trade for (or even roster) backup QBs so if he's not free, I'm good.

FWIW, the charts say Nix is just between 1.12 and 2.01 in SF and worth a 3rd in 1QB, so I think we're on the same page.

[NathanielWegman]

I think Fields has a much higher ceiling, so if I could get him+ for Nix I’m making the deal, unless my roster is dependent on a guy who could start this year

[Menace2010]

Nix was just drafted with the 12th overall pick. Fields was traded for a 6th. Fields may have another short-run in him, but he's also unlikely to lock down a starting gig.

[abloom]

Who would you rather?
Nix
Fields 3.06 25 third

12+ team SF give me Nix

Otherwise give me the third