Goff/Swift or BYoung/Hall

[OhSnapItsAnt]

Got offered this trade. Team in sig, 10 team SF

Give Goff, Swift, Shultz, 1.9

Get Bryce Young, Breece Hall

[Black Adam]

Way too much to pay for Hall; BY isn't worth much and may be out of a job if he doesn't improve this season.

[richardweston1233]

Goff side here. Young isn't very good, he's undersized so it's more likely than not that he will be a bust when it's all said and done. Hall isn't worth all that. Most RBs aren't when you look at their shelf life.

[tstafford]

It's a 10-team league, QB values aren't quite what they are in 12-team SF. Hall is the best piece in the deal. While I think it's an overpay, I don't think it's terrible.

[TheTroll]

While Hall is the best of this gaggle, I’m siding with the Goff side. Too much goodness here to give away but couldn’t fault you for getting Hall if he is your must have.

[frerichs5]

Hall side for me.

While I agree it may be paying a hair too much, I don’t think it’s egregious. Goff/Young is your QB3. While yes that has value and I’d rather have Goff, I’m not too worried about it. You probably need your top guys healthy to win anyway.

.5 PPR boosts RB value a little. Whoever you draft at 1.09 will have a hard time cracking your lineup, assuming it’s a WR. And if you decided to go RB, why not just go Hall?

All in all, paying a smidge too much? Maybe. But I think it makes your team better.

Edit: the more I think about it, I don’t think you’re even losing on value. I’m not sure I’d trade Breece for Goff + 1.09 in a 10 team, but I’m fine calling that equal. That leaves Young for Swift and Schultz. While I’m not a big Young fan, I’d still rather have him than those two.

[kellysheroes]

you got Allen and Burrow... give me Hall and hopefully Young turns it around

[NathanielWegman]

Because of roster construction, I’d make the move.

[OhSnapItsAnt]

I need a tie breaker here lol. Appreciate all the help.
What if I was able to knock off the pick?

Goff, Swift, Shultz

Young, Hall

[Menace2010]

No pick and I'm 100% onboard. With the pick and I'm torn, hammers are critical to win in a 10 team league, Hall is the only hammer, so I'd probably accept and hope Young bounces back.

[Edgy68]

Have to agree that Hall is a good piece. In a 10-team, it’s easier to get QBs, especially this draft.

If you get to hold your pick, even better.

[NathanielWegman]

If you can hold the pick, I make the deal

[Black Adam]

If you can hold the pick, I make the deal

x2