Maye + Nabers or MHJ + JJM

[RoyalPalmer]

Team one in the sig. Year two of a complete strip down, burn it to the ground rebuild. Own the 1.03 and 1.05 in a 12 team SF league. The 1.01 and 1.02 owners NEED a QB. So does the owner of 1.04 (who also owns 1.06).

I also need a QB and a lot a bit of everything (also own 1.10 + 2.01 + 3.01).

Do I go Maye at 3, meaning the that MHJ falls to 1.04 and then letting me take Nabers at 1.05
or
Do I go MHJ at 3, meaning Maye falls to 1.04 and I take JJM at 1.05? Hell or do I go MHJ + Nabers and get Nix/Penix later? I probably will be a bottom 3 team again next season.

[kellysheroes]

Maye and Nabers I think

[repkllrs]

I would be the reverse.

[RoyalPalmer]

This decision is going to haunt me for seasons. I just know it.

[Needalife]

This might seriously be the most difficult trade I've ever seen posted on this forum. Wow, I mean this is really close.

I'm going the Marvin side because I perceive both situations to be better than the other side of the deal but ooooph that's a tough question.

[TheTroll]

This might seriously be the most difficult trade I've ever seen posted on this forum. Wow, I mean this is really close.

I'm going the Marvin side because I perceive both situations to be better than the other side of the deal but ooooph that's a tough question.

Being the most difficult, I’m going the opposite side!

[tstafford]

MHJR/JJM for me.

[Menace2010]

Maye, Nabers for me, but I'm high on Maye long-term and don't think you can afford to miss with that roster. Don't like guys that fly up draft boards last minute. JJM is in a good situation, but may not be a good player...

[Black Adam]

MHj/JJM.

[RoyalPalmer]

Maye, Nabers for me, but I'm high on Maye long-term and don't think you can afford to miss with that roster. Don't like guys that fly up draft boards last minute. JJM is in a good situation, but may not be a good player...

Way more MHJ+JJM which is only somewhat surprising to me. My QB situation is probably the only reason why this is even a debate for me and why I'm leaning towards Maye + Nabers.

[Hankybro21]

MHJ JJM

[TheTroll]

This just proves you have a great problem to have! Not sure you can really make a mistake here

[Dynasty DeLorean]

Maye and Nabers I think

[NathanielWegman]

I’d go with MHJ & JJM

JJM is in the better spot. Maye has more upside, but in a bad situation for now…

But to me MHJ is much more valuable than Nabers from the get go and in the future. So that’s what sways it for me.

Also maybe the guy at 4 likes JJM more than Maye…then you get MHJ and Maye but zero chance he doesn’t take MHJ

[knotts4372]

i dont like either qb much so i resort to best player which by a good bit is mhjr side.