Trade Burrow or Richardson?

[Edgy68]

For Panthers, I have a fellow owner in need at QB who would like to trade up from 1.04 to my 1.02 (traded for, not earned). With both Burrow and Richardson with injury issues, he will begrudgingly send me the 1.04 and CJ Stroud for the 1.02, 1.06, and either Burrow or Richardson. The framework of this deal was my idea since I worry about too many injury issues affecting availability (the reason I earned 1.06 this year). Do my fears warrant a trade?

I know I could work out a deal using other players to move back as well. My overall goal is to take MHJ without having to use the 1.02 on him. I traded my 1.06 (and a 4th, a 5th, and K. Mitchell) for Mayfield, 2.03, and mid-2nd 2025 to the holder of the 1.03 to ensure he would have to go QB at that spot, so I’m fairly certain MHJ will be there at 1.04.

[Mtt33]

He will begrudgingly snap accept and run with that you mean. I’m low on Richardson and still want Richardson 1.02 and 1.06 very easily over stroud and 1.04.

[tstafford]

He will begrudgingly snap accept and run with that you mean. I’m low on Richardson and still want Richardson 1.02 and 1.06 very easily over stroud and 1.04.

That's my POV as well. This seems really expensive for Stroud.

[moishetreats]

I'm so confused.

How can you trade 1.06 if you already traded it?

And you're trading a QB (Burrow/Richardson) in a similar tier to Stroud to move down from 1.02 to 1.04 and also adding 1.06 (even though you already traded 1.06)?

Or maybe I'm misreading everything!

[TheTroll]

I'm so confused.

How can you trade 1.06 if you already traded it?

And you're trading a QB (Burrow/Richardson) in a similar tier to Stroud to move down from 1.02 to 1.04 and also adding 1.06 (even though you already traded 1.06)?

Or maybe I'm misreading everything!

I had to reread it too. A lot of info to take in

However, I do agree with the others now that deal is a lot for CJ Stroud

[Black Adam]

He will begrudgingly snap accept and run with that you mean. I’m low on Richardson and still want Richardson 1.02 and 1.06 very easily over stroud and 1.04.

Right? This is highway trade r*pe, don't do this Oh Pee!

[tstafford]

He will begrudgingly snap accept and run with that you mean. I’m low on Richardson and still want Richardson 1.02 and 1.06 very easily over stroud and 1.04.

Right? This is highway trade r*pe, don't do this Oh Pee!

Thought we'd kind of buried that term.

[Black Adam]

Thought we'd kind of buried that term.

I don't spend much time on here so I have no idea what "we" have done.

Ignore me then.

[knotts4372]

For Panthers, I have a fellow owner in need at QB who would like to trade up from 1.04 to my 1.02 (traded for, not earned). With both Burrow and Richardson with injury issues, he will begrudgingly send me the 1.04 and CJ Stroud for the 1.02, 1.06, and either Burrow or Richardson. The framework of this deal was my idea since I worry about too many injury issues affecting availability (the reason I earned 1.06 this year). Do my fears warrant a trade?

I know I could work out a deal using other players to move back as well. My overall goal is to take MHJ without having to use the 1.02 on him. I traded my 1.06 (and a 4th, a 5th, and K. Mitchell) for Mayfield, 2.03, and mid-2nd 2025 to the holder of the 1.03 to ensure he would have to go QB at that spot, so I’m fairly certain MHJ will be there at 1.04.

he's not "begrudgingly" trading anything. hes acting like hes losing when hes secretly trying to bend you over a barrel. to just throw out burrow like that is wild to me. richardson isnt quite so bad but his value is not far behind stroud on his own. keep 1.2 and ensure yourself marvin harrison jr there. dont try to get fancy with it

[murphysxm]

This is a massive overpay for Stroud. Zero interest