Justin Herbert value now.

[MacDaddy123]

I think it's heavily in favor of the Herbert side as is. With this adjustment, I think it's more even. Personally, I'd still want to hang onto Herbert for the next decade.

So Herbert + 2.05 for 1.02 and 1.07 leans even heavier to the Herbert side than Herbert + 1.12 for 1.02 + 1.07 does???

I'm not sure how your math works, or possibly you just are a Caleb hater?

I mean in my math, 2.05 is less valuable than 1.12, so it should lean further away from the Herbert side.

Let me try another way. Original trade bad. Counter offer less bad.

Sorry, my bad. My dyslexia had me read that as " with this adjustment, I think it is even more (bad).
After re-reading, you were right, it is more even.

Funny thing is, the 1.02 owner REALLY LOVES Caleb, and we have been in discussions for him to trade up from 1.02 to 1.01, so I could draft MHJ as I intended, but at 1.02 instead of 1.01, and pick up a little capital. 1.03 also needs a QB.

It's just that after yesterday, I told him that Herbert now concerns me, and maybe I need to pick Caleb at 1.01 instead of passing on him for MHJ. He immediately responded that he would give the 1.02 for Herbert.
That is what started me thinking about all of this. I knew that 1.02 for Herbert was too light.

I have not yet made an offer, just brain-storming.
I was pretty comfortable with my QB room until Herbert concerns that started with the Harbaugh hire, and reached peak concern level yesterday.