Robinson for Jefferson trade

[1coldone]

Sorry, more info:
1 QB
PPR

Value check

I give up:

Bijan Robinson
Justin Herbert

I get:

Justin Jefferson
Justin Fields

My qbs are
J Allen
Mahomes

My rbs:
Dowdle
Elliot
Ford
Kamara
McLaughin
Pollard
Z White

My WRs:
Iosivas
Mingo
Perry
D Robinson
Saheed
DeVonta Smith


Any thoughts much appreciated

[BabyChark23]

Bijan/ Herbert. Not close

[Menace2010]

Assuming Superflex, Bijan and Herbert by a massive margin. Herbert is going before Jefferson in most start-ups, or closely behind. Bijan isn't a small piece to add. Fields is trash...

[1coldone]

Sorry, my fault this is a
1 qb
full point PPR

Thanks for quick replies.

[Menace2010]

In a 1QB, I'm fine with this... You don't look competitive, so shipping RBs for Elite WRs makes sense. I'd look to keep selling RBs for WRs in that format. Build around Mahomes or Allen, Jefferson, and Smith.

[Mtt33]

Starting positions?

[1coldone]

9 starters
1 QB
1-4 WR
1-4 RB
1-4 TE
1 Kicker
1 Def

[BradyT]

Assuming Superflex, Bijan and Herbert by a massive margin. Herbert is going before Jefferson in most start-ups, or closely behind. Bijan isn't a small piece to add. Fields is trash...

Herbert before Jefferson??? I take Jefferson at #1, in superflex! Only QB I'd consider is Mahomes.

[Finfansteve]

Why don’t you just try to trade one of mahomes or Allen and add a little to either for JJ?

Actually I’d trade 2 of your 3 qbs for whatever you can get in a 1qb league I just looked at your roster you need a lot of help if I’m reading it right

[Dynasty DeLorean]

Why don’t you just try to trade one of mahomes or Allen and add a little to either for JJ?

Actually I’d trade 2 of your 3 qbs for whatever you can get in a 1qb league I just looked at your roster you need a lot of help if I’m reading it right

Yeah the current deal doesn’t make sense. JJ > Bijan but Herbert more than covers the difference

[Finfansteve]

Why don’t you just try to trade one of mahomes or Allen and add a little to either for JJ?

Actually I’d trade 2 of your 3 qbs for whatever you can get in a 1qb league I just looked at your roster you need a lot of help if I’m reading it right

Yeah the current deal doesn’t make sense. JJ > Bijan but Herbert more than covers the difference

But then he’s left trying to replace a stud rb thru the draft. I’d almost rather try to find stud wrs in the draft as that seems to be each drafts strengths the last several years and most likely going forward

[TheTroll]

In 1 QB, that is too light for JJ

[dblj1199]

Your team looks to be several players away. I'd prefer the wr over the rb here long term. I think I'm looking to sell off one of the 3 qbs separately if possible, but I want youth and picks.

[1coldone]

An update.

Thanks for the thoughts and replies. I did talk with the owner and threw out Mahomes and Allen (if either one would move the needle for them) are available for this type of trade and my concern was the Herbert for Fields part. The offer he sent back is in the other thread. which is

Give
Bijan robinson
Z White
A Iosivas

Get
J Jefferson
Miles sanders
Devin singletary
2.12
3.12

my thoughts

JJ the best piece
B Robinson pretty close 2nd and could be potentially only behind CMC as top RB (going forward)

Z white (top of deapth chart currently) and Iosivas both protentional upside...probably nothing special, IF they pan out

Miles sanders- hot garbage
Singletary is JAG

Late 2nd and 3rd, probably won't make the roster and that is saying something on my awful roster...lol. I have the 1.06, 2.06 and 3.06. So, 3 higher picks. 21 roster spots and must keep a Kicker and Def, at all times.

Am I off base here?

[BabyChark23]

An update.

Thanks for the thoughts and replies. I did talk with the owner and threw out Mahomes and Allen (if either one would move the needle for them) are available for this type of trade and my concern was the Herbert for Fields part. The offer he sent back is in the other thread. which is

Give Bijan robinson
Z White
A Iosivas

Get
J Jefferson
Miles sanders
Devin singletary
2.12
3.12

my thoughts

JJ the best piece
B Robinson pretty close 2nd and could be potentially only behind CMC as top RB (going forward)

Z white and Iosivas protentional upside...probably nothing special, IF they pan out

Miles sanders- hot garbage
Singletary is JAG

Late 2nd and 3rd, probably won't make the roster and that is saying something on my awful roster...lol

Am I off base here?

I’d do this deal. I prefer Jefferson side by a fair bit here.