Tua v Love

[QueenCity25]

Where does the board side with these 2?

Thinking about trading Tua to the owner hill

[Gator Sens]

Both are good QBs moving forward. I don't see a huge difference between the two value wise and it's likely a preference deal or depends on what can be added to either side. Tua is slightly more proven, but again, good options both ways.

[Sriracha]

I'm higher on Love than most so take this with a grain of salt but Love just outproduced Tua as a first year starter with a significantly worse supporting cast.

He's also a much more physically talented QB.

As far as fantasy points scored in 2024 they're probably similar but I'd argue Love's ceiling is significantly higher if some of these young weapons can make a jump this off-season.

[Anteaters]

Personal preference, though I lean Tua because he more of a proven product.
If you want Love, it's a perfectly legitimate trade.

[tstafford]

Personal preference, though I lean Tua because he more of a proven product.
If you want Love, it's a perfectly legitimate trade.

This is how I feel.

[TheTroll]

Personal preference, though I lean Tua because he more of a proven product.
If you want Love, it's a perfectly legitimate trade.

This is how I feel.

X3

[The.Big.Spank]

I'm higher on Love than most so take this with a grain of salt but Love just outproduced Tua as a first year starter with a significantly worse supporting cast.

He's also a much more physically talented QB.

As far as fantasy points scored in 2024 they're probably similar but I'd argue Love's ceiling is significantly higher if some of these young weapons can make a jump this off-season.

This is how I feel.

[moishetreats]

Love had more total points and a higher average points-per-game in 2023 than Tua has ever had in his career.

[MacDaddy123]

I have Love fairly well ahead of Tua on my lists.

[stpilots98]

Love for me by a decent amount

[Yogurt]

I'm a fan of both but I think we've seen Tua's ceiling this past season. As others have mentioned, Love outperformed Tua as a 1st year starter with worse weapons. It'd be Love > Tua for me.

[murphysxm]

I prefer Love. I think he has a higher ceiling and has a much cleaner injury history.

[Needalife]

I prefer Love. I think he has a higher ceiling and has a much cleaner injury history.

Totally agree here. Feels like a different tier to me. I think Love is closest with Herbert in current value. Not sure who I'm going with there.

[Payton34]

Not entirely convinced that Love is THAT great yet, but certainly had a great year.

I feel that Tua's value is tied to Tyreek and we will likely see a cataclysmic drop off from Tua once Hill is gone.