2024 Bad Trade Offers

[wickerkat1212]

I said I wanted more picks. 1 QB 1 PPR 12-man league.

This is the offer I got:

I Give: 2025 2nd (probably late, between 9-12)
I Get: 2024 3.10, 4.09, 4.10

I'd love more picks, but not like that.

[Menace2010]

I said I wanted more picks. 1 QB 1 PPR 12-man league.

This is the offer I got:

I Give: 2025 2nd (probably late, between 9-12)
I Get: 2024 3.10, 4.09, 4.10

I'd love more picks, but not like that.

Not a particularly bad offer. The "standard" price of a 3rd in the current season is a 2nd in a future year. 3.10, so obviously a 2nd is a tall ask, but adding 2x 4ths balances it out a bit...

[Jigga94]

I said I wanted more picks. 1 QB 1 PPR 12-man league.

This is the offer I got:

I Give: 2025 2nd (probably late, between 9-12)
I Get: 2024 3.10, 4.09, 4.10

I'd love more picks, but not like that.

Not a particularly bad offer. The "standard" price of a 3rd in the current season is a 2nd in a future year. 3.10, so obviously a 2nd is a tall ask, but adding 2x 4ths balances it out a bit...

Yup

[trc]

I said I wanted more picks. 1 QB 1 PPR 12-man league.

This is the offer I got:

I Give: 2025 2nd (probably late, between 9-12)
I Get: 2024 3.10, 4.09, 4.10

I'd love more picks, but not like that.

Not a particularly bad offer. The "standard" price of a 3rd in the current season is a 2nd in a future year. 3.10, so obviously a 2nd is a tall ask, but adding 2x 4ths balances it out a bit...

Yup

Agree

[wickerkat1212]

I said I wanted more picks. 1 QB 1 PPR 12-man league.

This is the offer I got:

I Give: 2025 2nd (probably late, between 9-12)
I Get: 2024 3.10, 4.09, 4.10

I'd love more picks, but not like that.

Not a particularly bad offer. The "standard" price of a 3rd in the current season is a 2nd in a future year. 3.10, so obviously a 2nd is a tall ask, but adding 2x 4ths balances it out a bit...

It's more picks, sure, but pretty late and in a 1 QB league, the 3.10 has some value but the 4th are total dart throws. Wish that third was earlier. I know it's a deep WR class but I have to expect those guys are gone by 3.10 and certainly that late in the fourth. I haven't rejected it yet, that's why I posted it here, expecting it to be a bad offer. But you're all making me rethink it.

[Menace2010]

I said I wanted more picks. 1 QB 1 PPR 12-man league.

This is the offer I got:

I Give: 2025 2nd (probably late, between 9-12)
I Get: 2024 3.10, 4.09, 4.10

I'd love more picks, but not like that.

Not a particularly bad offer. The "standard" price of a 3rd in the current season is a 2nd in a future year. 3.10, so obviously a 2nd is a tall ask, but adding 2x 4ths balances it out a bit...

It's more picks, sure, but pretty late and in a 1 QB league, the 3.10 has some value but the 4th are total dart throws. Wish that third was earlier. I know it's a deep WR class but I have to expect those guys are gone by 3.10 and certainly that late in the fourth. I haven't rejected it yet, that's why I posted it here, expecting it to be a bad offer. But you're all making me rethink it.

To clarify. I wouldn't take the deal. It's just not something I'd ever consider posting in the bad offers thread; offers posted here are supposed to be egregious.

[wickerkat1212]

Not a particularly bad offer. The "standard" price of a 3rd in the current season is a 2nd in a future year. 3.10, so obviously a 2nd is a tall ask, but adding 2x 4ths balances it out a bit...

It's more picks, sure, but pretty late and in a 1 QB league, the 3.10 has some value but the 4th are total dart throws. Wish that third was earlier. I know it's a deep WR class but I have to expect those guys are gone by 3.10 and certainly that late in the fourth. I haven't rejected it yet, that's why I posted it here, expecting it to be a bad offer. But you're all making me rethink it.

To clarify. I wouldn't take the deal. It's just not something I'd ever consider posting in the bad offers thread; offers posted here are supposed to be egregious.

Thanks. Appreciate that.

[FiremanEd]

I said I wanted more picks. 1 QB 1 PPR 12-man league.

This is the offer I got:

I Give: 2025 2nd (probably late, between 9-12)
I Get: 2024 3.10, 4.09, 4.10

I'd love more picks, but not like that.

Package those 3 picks gets you to the top half of the 3rd. With 2nd a year away and projected late, you’re giving a few draft spots for current draft participation and multiple shots. Very logical offer. Hardly Bad Trade Offer worthy. Seems more like a standard decline type offer.

[Bronco Billy]

I said I wanted more picks. 1 QB 1 PPR 12-man league.

This is the offer I got:

I Give: 2025 2nd (probably late, between 9-12)
I Get: 2024 3.10, 4.09, 4.10

I'd love more picks, but not like that.

What were you expecting? To move back 4 spots and add a couple of 4ths? That offer looks pretty solid to me as well.

[wickerkat1212]

I said I wanted more picks. 1 QB 1 PPR 12-man league.

This is the offer I got:

I Give: 2025 2nd (probably late, between 9-12)
I Get: 2024 3.10, 4.09, 4.10

I'd love more picks, but not like that.

What were you expecting? To move back 4 spots and add a couple of 4ths? That offer looks pretty solid to me as well.

Well, it's not moving back four it's moving back a whole round. 2.10 or so for 3.10, 4.09, 4.10.
If I had a strong send of the dart throws in the 4th I might take it. I'm trying counters.

[wickerkat1212]

Superflex, 12-man, 1 ppr. We start qb-rb-rb-wr-wr-wr-te-superflex-flex-k-d.
My team is Superflex #1 in my signature.
The guy who won last year made an offer for Bijan. Offered

Heinicke, Taylor ATL QB
Minshew, Gardner LVR QB
Year 2024 Draft Pick 4.03
Year 2024 Draft Pick 4.04
Year 2024 Draft Pick 4.12
Year 2025 Round 1 Draft Pick from Hawk #12 (late)
Year 2025 Round 2 Draft Pick from Hawk #12 (late)
Year 2026 Round 1 Draft Pick from Hawk #12 (late)

for

Bijan
ARodgers

[saw061600]

And the first trade offer of the year is a super fantastic offer.
1QB
Give: Achane
Get: Dameon Pierce, KJ Osborn, 3.08, 3.09

The offering owner should be smote down by the fantasy Gods. Here my prayers oh dark gods of fantasy.

[Jigga94]

And the first trade offer of the year is a super fantastic offer.
1QB
Give: Achane
Get: Dameon Pierce, KJ Osborn, 3.08, 3.09

The offering owner should be smote down by the fantasy Gods. Here my prayers oh dark gods of fantasy.

Eww

[wickerkat1212]

And the first trade offer of the year is a super fantastic offer.
1QB
Give: Achane
Get: Dameon Pierce, KJ Osborn, 3.08, 3.09

The offering owner should be smote down by the fantasy Gods. Here my prayers oh dark gods of fantasy.

That's not even four quarters for a dollar. Four dimes. Damn. Terrible.

[MacDaddy123]

This trade just went through in my 14 team SF TEP league, I had to laugh my butt off:

Calvin Ridley
DK Metcalf
Gardner Minshew
Trey McBride
25 late 2nd

for

Kyler Murray
Garrett Wilson
2024 1.12