Dynasty League Football Forum

Which would you prefer? Team offered McKinney in a deal for Battle and Poyer.

Battle is promising and has performed well the last two weeks. Poyer is solid, but also aging. McKinney seems like a solid combination of the two, but obviously has contract concerns with this being his last year under contract...

I have depth at S, so this would also free up a roster spot currently being used on a DB (likely for whenever someone comes off IR, the waiver is thin)...

Always treat safeties as redraft.

That doesn’t necessarily make this a no-brainer either way, as both Battle and McKinney project to spend a lot of time soaking up snaps on bad teams down the stretch.

Since it IS dynasty tho, I think it’s fair to use future value as a tie-breaker. Keep battle.

But it’s a coin toss

I'd want Battle, as he looks like he is now ready to take over Vonn Bell's role as SS.
Bell was very successful in that Bengals defense for many years.