Dynasty League Football Forum

10 team .5 PPR (team in sig), I was offered the following trade this morning:

Give: Garrett Wilson/Swift
Receive: Barkley/JSN

Thoughts?

Barkley and jsn for me and not particularly close

Garrett and Swift for me. While I like JSN, I don't see him ever having the type of upside Garrett does, who is a top 6 dynasty wideout for me. Given you're not a contender, I'd build around the stud wideout.

Barkley really struggles to stay on the field and Wilson is easily the best long term piece here. All in, I could see the Barkley side for this year but otherwise, Wilson +. Swift is injury prone too, so I would take the best overall piece.

I guess I should add to my post given the last two responses. I view Barkley as the best short term piece here and jsn as the best long term piece. Yes I have JSN potential higher than Wilson's potential

I’m super high on JSN, which makes this one really tough. I think Wilson is the best piece long term still and Swift could get unlocked in the Philly offense, even if not to the extent/workload of Week 2. I would take Wilson/Swift, but couldn’t blame you for going either way.

im a contender and im afraid of barkley and the giants so hes not someone i highly recommend buying. team is bad, his ankle is tweaked, hes got no long term deal, just makes me scared to invest. currently optimistic about swift and his rest of season upside. i think i like wilson swift for both win now and rebuild