Bradford or Freeman?

[sunnyd23]

Two QB's that have obviously underperformed this season. Who would you rather have. I personally like Bradford the way the NFL is set up, but Freeman has better pieces around him and the threat of running. What say you???

[tra151]

I would rather have Bradford. I don't think freeman has very much upside. I think Bradford has a chance to "get it" at some point and be a fantasy factor.

[blacksheep]

I agree. I'd rather have Bradford. By quite alot actually. Down year for him so don't sell low on him if you have to. Don't get me wrong, Freeman is nice to have but Bradford will be around for a lot longer and will make more of an impact.

[tstafford]

I'd rather own which ever one I could get cheaper in a trade or later in a start-up draft. One thing that no one has mentioned is that Freeman has already proven he can be a fantasy QB1. In a 6pt/TD league, he was the QB#7 in 2010.

[northga]

I'd rather roster Freeman. He is having a subpar year compared to last year but a lot that rests on the OC in Tampa. Olson had been an OC twice before being hired as a QB coach and then was hurriedly promoted in right before the last preseason game of 2009 whem R.Morris fired his OC. Last year, the Bucs caught Defenses by surprise but this year the Defenses have wised up and Olson hasn't changed his game plan to adapt.

[voiceofunreason]

Two QB's that have obviously underperformed this season. Who would you rather have. I personally like Bradford the way the NFL is set up, but Freeman has better pieces around him and the threat of running. What say you???

I disagree with Freeman having better pieces. They are both in crappy situations and need some elite talent from the draft next year.

Williams - possible bust
Benn - likely bust
Briscoe - middle round pick, been around the league and wasn't good enough for other teams - no production
Parker - slot wr at best
Winslow - a million injuries from the accident, probably not going to play a lot longer at a decent level
Blount - way overrated due to incredibly easy schedule last year and doesn't catch at all

I don't think their situations are that different. All comes down to who you believe in and, as above, depends a large amount on what the particualar owners want for them.

[prinefan]

Bradford for me. Give him a couple more weapons and he'll be very productive.

[henry1jg]

Freeman for me, the fact hat he's a running threat on top of what he's already shown just makes me believe more in him.

[MilwaukeesBest]

I would rather have Bradford. I don't think freeman has very much upside. I think Bradford has a chance to "get it" at some point and be a fantasy factor.

I like Sam as well. Esp if they manage to re-sign Lloyd.