JK Dobbins or Nick Bosa - who ya got?

[jbz420]

IDP valuations are really difficult to nail down. Got an offer for team 2 in my sig of JK for Nick Bosa. I need some DL help and plan to draft Will Anderson (hopefully). I value JK in this draft around 1.5/1.6. DLF calc agress that his value is around 1.5. If i were to take a stab at where i would draft Nick Bosa in this draft, it'd be around 1.8. I countered with JK for Bosa + 24 2nd, but offer was declined. What do you all think? Would you rate Bosa higher than a 1.8 and perhaps equal in value to Dobbins?

thx

[lukkynumber13]

If this is a league where Bosa is scoring 15-20+ PPG, and you’re starting 2-4 DEs per week, then MAYBE I take Bosa.

Last year I’d take Bosa over dobbins for sure, if it’s that type of league format.

However, now that MFL went to stupid true position so now there’s twice as many DEs on everyone’s rosters, I’d take Dobbins over Bosa no matter the format.

[killer_of_giants]

still, knowing the format would help in giving an opinion!

[TB3falcons]

I'd take Bosa but I am low on J'Kaylin overall. Entering his 4th year in the league and realistically this could be his final year of relevancy (RB entering a contract year who hasn't proved anything 3 years in the league...)

[Menace2010]

Unless the scoring is insanely high for IDPs, I'm not moving a RB2 for a DE. Most of my leagues are tackle not sack heavy so usually you can find some options to start relatively late and or on the Waivers. That's rarely possible for a RB.

[Oddball456]

As others have said, depends on starting requirements. And note that I haven't looked into how many LB got switched over to DE this offseason. But given equivalent starting requirements, I like a locked in high end choice in Bosa where the quality of DEs drops off fairly quick compared to a bit of unknown in Dobbins.