Mingo vs Tillman vs Reed

[JTLoh]

I also would hate getting the WR9 last year for a mid-late 1st...

14th by fantasy points per game, and it would be a mid, not mid-late.
Thanks for the Spin, FoxNews.

[Cameron Giles]

Matt Harmon is positively gushing over Reed on twitter. He’s got a serious man crush on him. Nice to have someone like that reinforcing your decision if you drafted Reed like I did.

Very surprised Reed isn't getting any love here

[Jigga94]

I also would hate getting the WR9 last year for a mid-late 1st...

14th by fantasy points per game, and it would be a mid, not mid-late.
Thanks for the Spin, FoxNews.

Whatever helps you sleep

[Jigga94]

Matt Harmon is positively gushing over Reed on twitter. He’s got a serious man crush on him. Nice to have someone like that reinforcing your decision if you drafted Reed like I did.

Very surprised Reed isn't getting any love here

Let's keep it that way haha

[Bronco Billy]

Matt Harmon is positively gushing over Reed on twitter. He’s got a serious man crush on him. Nice to have someone like that reinforcing your decision if you drafted Reed like I did.

Very surprised Reed isn't getting any love here

Geez, it’s really starting to gain some momentum. Seeing a few opinions that think he can be a WR1 in GB matched with Watson. I like him a lot but did not expect that.

[JTLoh]

Whatever helps you sleep

If there were a thumbs up button here, I would push it.

[JTLoh]

I feel like this should be more of a
Mingo vs Tillman
Reed vs Mims

[Bronco Billy]

I feel like this should be more of a
Mingo vs Tillman
Reed vs Mims

Why? Mingo’s ADP is well ahead of the other 3, who in order are #23 for Mims, #27 for Reed and #30 for Tillman per 279 rookie drafts on mfl.

Seems like maybe your opinion is more of an outlier - not that there’s anything wrong with that, but it sure doesn’t warrant another similar thread.

[JTLoh]

Seems like maybe your opinion is more of an outlier - not that there’s anything wrong with that, but it sure doesn’t warrant another similar thread.

I just feel like Mims and Reed are similar type receivers. And Tillman/Mingo are more similar to each other than Mims/Reed.

[wickerkat1212]

Seems like maybe your opinion is more of an outlier - not that there’s anything wrong with that, but it sure doesn’t warrant another similar thread.

I just feel like Mims and Reed are similar type receivers. And Tillman/Mingo are more similar to each other than Mims/Reed.

I started this as these were three WRs that I had my eye on and thought they were getting similar ADP, then the more we dug in, the more I saw some separation. It's a fascinating study, and I also like Rice and Mims in the mix, but just wanted to see what people thought of these three. Mingo is the clear leader of these three IMO.

[FantasyFreak]

Along with Devonta, Tee Higgins has the same benefit. It's not a bad thing, if you have a QB that can support it, and Cousins can.

Except, I don't wanna spend 1.5 - 1.8 on a Devonta Smith. Which is where I see Addison going.
If its TEP, I'll take Kincaid or trade out.

I mean, Devonta Smith had 95 grabs for about 1200 yards and 7 TD's last year, in his 2nd year in the league. He was a top 10 WR in PPR. I'd take that production every year for my 1.08 pick.

[JTLoh]

Yeah, I'll reconsider. Devonta was better that I was giving him credit for.

But i'm still sus on Addison. But more about, can Cousins support both? Actually it would be all three, because Hock is gonna get targets.
I'd draft Addison, but after 1.8 for me. And I haven't looked but how much of Smith's production came after Goedart went down? Is/was he top 15ish WR with a healthy Goedart?

[JTLoh]

I started this as these were three WRs that I had my eye on and thought they were getting similar ADP, then the more we dug in, the more I saw some separation. It's a fascinating study, and I also like Rice and Mims in the mix, but just wanted to see what people thought of these three. Mingo is the clear leader of these three IMO.

No worries mate. It's a fine thread.
I was just OTC and torn between Reed/Mims and found this while searching for answers.

[Cameron Giles]

Yeah, I'll reconsider. Devonta was better that I was giving him credit for.

But i'm still sus on Addison. But more about, can Cousins support both? Actually it would be all three, because Hock is gonna get targets.
I'd draft Addison, but after 1.8 for me. And I haven't looked but how much of Smith's production came after Goedart went down? Is/was he top 15ish WR with a healthy Goedart?

Cousins has supported multiple T-24 WRs and TE1 play simultaneously throughout his career.

Players with Addison's production profile typically hit. It's just a matter of how big of a hit they are. Addison is closer to a Calvin Ridley-Christian Kirk type of player, which if awesome for fantasy.

He's going to a team that:

- T-3 in pass attempts last year
- May trade Dalvin Cook, locking them into a more pass-heavy offense
- 107 targets from Adam Thielen gone
- Bad WR depth behind Justin Jefferson
- Spent 1st Round DC on him

Plus, he's rarely going to see primary coverage with Justin Jefferson on the field. It's not sexy, but it's a pretty safe pick.

[wickerkat1212]

I started this as these were three WRs that I had my eye on and thought they were getting similar ADP, then the more we dug in, the more I saw some separation. It's a fascinating study, and I also like Rice and Mims in the mix, but just wanted to see what people thought of these three. Mingo is the clear leader of these three IMO.

No worries mate. It's a fine thread.
I was just OTC and torn between Reed/Mims and found this while searching for answers.

Right on. Best of luck.