Anyone have Dynasty Trade Calculator and can run this trade for me?

[lilpuppy99]

Dynasty 12 team 1 QB PPR.


Team A- Garrett Wilson

Team B- G Pickens and K Herbert(Bears backup RB)


Wondering how far off this is. Thank you.

[Gator Sens]

Calculators are never trustworthy or accurate ha ha. This is off by a mid 1st-ish (at least) I am guessing. Pickens has decent value but not great whereas Wilson is one of the hottest names in dynasty this summer. Herbert has average value and the Bears bringing in Foreman really hurts is value spike that he had for a few weeks.

[BucBuc]

Off by a mid 1st…I’d even argue and early 1st

[murphysxm]

Don't need a calculator to tell you the Wilson side wins easily

[abloom]

Why do you think Herbert is a backup?

As others have said, don't use calculators, they are worthless.

Definitely off by a mid first.

[ESKAY]

Since no one else wanted to do a calculator I did. It has Wilson at 9000 and the other 2 at 7700. I’m shocked at the value of Herbert on there. Herbert was like 3000 which I think is ridiculously high.

[Jrblaha]

My calc has Herbert lower and the non-Wilson side needing to add 2023 1.4 to even the trade out, which makes sense imo. As a Wilson owner I wouldn’t want Pickens + Hebert + 1.4 for Wilson, but I see a decent drop off from 1.3 to 1.4

[lilpuppy99]

Yeah. I have no idea how Herbert has any value after they signed Foreman to be the lead back.

[saw061600]

calculators are very influenced by ADP. So they are only somewhat valid for players in situations that have a history of consistency. New signings, draft, injuries, sudden jump or decline in use, all take time to reflect in calculators.

[abloom]

Yeah. I have no idea how Herbert has any value after they signed Foreman to be the lead back.

Because one of the factors that determine player value on that calculator is either not updated or someone doesn't agree with what his value should be.

Unless you actually know how a calculator works (as in what factors go into the values, when they are updated, etc.) They are completely useless

[ESKAY]

I checked on keep trade cut which I think a lot of people use. I always check the calculators to see what they say but I would never accept a trade just because of them. But Herbert is exactly half the value of Wilson. Nobody in their right mind thinks that is accurate. But at the same time it says the piece you would have to add is a Tyreek Hill or Travis Kelce. Now that makes sense to me.

[TheTroll]

I checked on keep trade cut which I think a lot of people use. I always check the calculators to see what they say but I would never accept a trade just because of them. But Herbert is exactly half the value of Wilson. Nobody in their right mind thinks that is accurate. But at the same time it says the piece you would have to add is a Tyreek Hill or Travis Kelce. Now that makes sense to me.

For sure

[murphysxm]

KTC is not a resource you should ever use other than to take advantage of people who think it is valuable.

[Dynasty DeLorean]

I checked on keep trade cut which I think a lot of people use. I always check the calculators to see what they say but I would never accept a trade just because of them. But Herbert is exactly half the value of Wilson. Nobody in their right mind thinks that is accurate. But at the same time it says the piece you would have to add is a Tyreek Hill or Travis Kelce. Now that makes sense to me.

It says that but if you add two players of Herbert’s value together it won’t equal Wilson, it will be less. If you add another player of Herbert’s value (3100) to the Herbert side, it also adds 3000 to the Wilson side, making the deal no closer. KTC can’t be accurate in every situation but it’s a good rough estimate.

[BigBawseRoss]

KTC is not a resource you should ever use other than to take advantage of people who think it is valuable.

i think its fine to see if a deal is close enough or it helps me figure out what to add and then i hope they plug the deal into it and see they are winning lol