Walker vs Dean

[derekhiny]

Quay Walker vs Nakobe Dean

I'll be drafting one of these guys today, and I'm torn on who to take. I'm a die hard Eagles fan, but trying to leave my personal bias out of this. Lol. Any help would be appreciated.

Scoring - Tackles 2pts, Sacks 5 points, TFLs 3 points. Stackable.

[FiremanEd]

I never saw a special player in Quay. He was a role player IMO on an elite D, with many other better players. The Packers draft picks don’t impress me under this regime, and that draft capital is likely the basis of his rise in value (which is combined with his physical measurables). I am very hesitant on him as a player, and then you have Campbell…

Dean is half the athlete Quay is, and the injury concern we have to take at face value given we aren’t doctors or have all the info, but he is a cerebral player who has performed at the peak of a elite D. Him vs Quay wasn’t debatable IMO.

I would take Dean, but am admittedly cautious.

[derekhiny]

Thanks, Fireman. Walker ended up going earlier than expected anyways, so I ended up with Dean by default.