Somewhat early 2024 Draft thread

[BabyChark23]

1 QB league

Would you rather have the 3.03 or the 3.09 + 3.10?

I kind of like having more picks even this late.

I currently have 1.01, 2.10, 3.01, 3.02, 3.09, 3.10.
Like the idea of three picks in a row with the 3.01-3.03
but those 8/9 picks may be pretty similar guys, and I'd get two bites at the apple.

Thoughts?

3.03. I'd move up now. Some guy people want usually falls. You'd likely get a later 3rd and future 2nd if that happens. It's easier to move up now, rather than later, I have found, in general.

I'd say do it this year, especially, because the RB class is so weak.

My guess is you're going to be mid/late round 2 and wondering who the hell you want, it's so barren. Do it.

Agreed.

[YouMightDieTryin]

1 QB league

Would you rather have the 3.03 or the 3.09 + 3.10?

I kind of like having more picks even this late.

I currently have 1.01, 2.10, 3.01, 3.02, 3.09, 3.10.
Like the idea of three picks in a row with the 3.01-3.03
but those 8/9 picks may be pretty similar guys, and I'd get two bites at the apple.

Thoughts?

3.03. I'd move up now. Some guy people want usually falls. You'd likely get a later 3rd and future 2nd if that happens. It's easier to move up now, rather than later, I have found, in general.

I'd say do it this year, especially, because the RB class is so weak.

My guess is you're going to be mid/late round 2 and wondering who the hell you want, it's so barren. Do it.

Agreed.

Yep

[wickerkat1212]

Cool thanks guys.

[Menace2010]

Klassen at RP posted Penix’ charted throws on X

https://twitter.com/QBKlass/status/1778121028381843676

Do we have this for any other QBs? I'm trying to figure out if say Bo Nix is worth a late SuperFlex 1st. I'm also trying to figure out who I prefer in the Daniels and Maye debate (hot take, I'm currently way higher on Maye, but feel like I'm getting worn down by everyone else's analysis telling me I'm wrong).

[Bronco Billy]

Klassen at RP posted Penix’ charted throws on X

https://twitter.com/QBKlass/status/1778121028381843676

Do we have this for any other QBs? I'm trying to figure out if say Bo Nix is worth a late SuperFlex 1st. I'm also trying to figure out who I prefer in the Daniels and Maye debate (hot take, I'm currently way higher on Maye, but feel like I'm getting worn down by everyone else's analysis telling me I'm wrong).

RP has all of the top 6 rookie QBs charted. I won’t post Nix’ chart because it’s behind a paywall. I posted Penix’ because they made it public on X.

This was their final comment on Nix based on their charting and analysis that I will post:

Nix is more likely a capable backup with moments of quality starting play. Somewhere between Gardner Minshew and Andy Dalton should be the realistic expectation. Anything more than that is a cherry on top.

ETA - RP doesn’t compare the rookies directly but I get the impression they’re higher on Maye than Daniels. Daniels charted the best of all 6 QBs, but they’re concerned that he may not translate as well in pocket management, decision making and under pressure. Maye on the other hand didn’t chart as well but his strengths were deep balls, tight windows, pocket awareness and absolutely torching pressure. Those are all very highly desirable traits going to the bigs.

[Menace2010]

Klassen at RP posted Penix’ charted throws on X

https://twitter.com/QBKlass/status/1778121028381843676

Do we have this for any other QBs? I'm trying to figure out if say Bo Nix is worth a late SuperFlex 1st. I'm also trying to figure out who I prefer in the Daniels and Maye debate (hot take, I'm currently way higher on Maye, but feel like I'm getting worn down by everyone else's analysis telling me I'm wrong).

RP has all of the top 6 rookie QBs charted. I won’t post Nix’ chart because it’s behind a paywall. I posted Penix’ because they made it public on X.

This was their final comment on Nix based on their charting and analysis that I will post:

Nix is more likely a capable backup with moments of quality starting play. Somewhere between Gardner Minshew and Andy Dalton should be the realistic expectation. Anything more than that is a cherry on top.

ETA - RP doesn’t compare the rookies directly but I get the impression they’re higher on Maye than Daniels. Daniels charted the best of all 6 QBs, but they’re concerned that he may not translate as well in pocket management, decision making and under pressure. Maye on the other hand didn’t chart as well but his strengths were deep balls, tight windows, pocket awareness and absolutely torching pressure. Those are all very highly desirable traits going to the bigs.

Much, much appreciated! Thanks for sharing, and not violating any copyrights haha.

[81-]

Is it too early to start the 27 draft thread. Smith. Common name. Uncommon talent

[wickerkat1212]

You have two picks, you are OTC.
You already drafted Harrison WR and Bowers TE.
Which two are you taking?
Superflex, 1 PPR, TEP (2 total points per reception)

Benson RB
McConkey WR
Pearsall WR
Nix QB
Wright RB

[Bronco Billy]

You have two picks, you are OTC.
You already drafted Harrison WR and Bowers TE.
Which two are you taking?
Superflex, 1 PPR, TEP (2 total points per reception)

Benson RB
McConkey WR
Pearsall WR
Nix QB
Wright RB

I’m not a Nix fan and question if he’ll be any kind of a regular starter in the bigs. Benson is tempting depending on where he lands but I’m absolutely head over heels for both McConkey and Pearsall. They may not be alphas but I think both guys are difference makers who have pro ready skill sets. I’m not overly crazy about Wright either.

Make mine the WRs. Worst case you turn them into better vets at other positions if you get overloaded with talented WRs.

[BabyChark23]

You have two picks, you are OTC.
You already drafted Harrison WR and Bowers TE.
Which two are you taking?
Superflex, 1 PPR, TEP (2 total points per reception)

Benson RB
McConkey WR
Pearsall WR
Nix QB
Wright RB

I have Benson, McConkey, and Wright well ahead of the others in talent. That said, the answer to this question depends completely on draft capital and landing spot.

[murphysxm]

You have two picks, you are OTC.
You already drafted Harrison WR and Bowers TE.
Which two are you taking?
Superflex, 1 PPR, TEP (2 total points per reception)

Benson RB
McConkey WR
Pearsall WR
Nix QB
Wright RB

I’m not a Nix fan and question if he’ll be any kind of a regular starter in the bigs. Benson is tempting depending on where he lands but I’m absolutely head over heels for both McConkey and Pearsall. They may not be alphas but I think both guys are difference makers who have pro ready skill sets. I’m not overly crazy about Wright either.

Make mine the WRs. Worst case you turn them into better vets at other positions if you get overloaded with talented WRs.

I am not seeing it in McConkey, seems pretty limited to me. Agree on Pearsall.

[Menace2010]

You have two picks, you are OTC.
You already drafted Harrison WR and Bowers TE.
Which two are you taking?
Superflex, 1 PPR, TEP (2 total points per reception)

Benson RB
McConkey WR
Pearsall WR
Nix QB
Wright RB

Benson and McConkey, unless Nix lands in a prime spot with 1st round capital.

[tstafford]

You have two picks, you are OTC.
You already drafted Harrison WR and Bowers TE.
Which two are you taking?
Superflex, 1 PPR, TEP (2 total points per reception)

Benson RB
McConkey WR
Pearsall WR
Nix QB
Wright RB

Benson and McConkey, unless Nix lands in a prime spot with 1st round capital.

Which he well might.

[FantasyFreak]

Caleb.

[lic217]

Wright for sure

Tgen probably benson