Mahomes or Herbert + Stevenson

[Benchwarmer101]

Superflex 1 ppr. BB format

Am I crazy to trade Mahomes away for Herbert + Stevenson? I have Herbert as a close 3rd to Mahomes. I also see Stevenson having a few big years in that offense. I would t do this if it was t BB. My other QB of note is Josh Allen.

[Gator Sens]

I would still lean Mahomes here. Stevenson could hit but is a gamble and Mahomes has the value.

[lt1hawk337]

Complements on the strong team. Kind of a coin flip to me. You don't really need the depth at RB (at least on paper), so I guess there could be an opportunity to flip Stevenson. That would be the upside of the trade to me. I value Mahomes a hair higher and he has the name cache'.

[The.Big.Spank]

I would much rather have Mahomes. Downgrading qb's to get Stevenson makes no sense to me.

[Tripwired]

I'd prefer to hold Mahomes here. I don't think Stevenson is enough to tier down for me.

[IR1]

Piling on, I’d want a better piece than Stevenson

[Needalife]

I feel like you can do better. This really depends on how much you like Herbert vs Mahomes. From a rankings standpoint, Mahomes has been going after Josh Allen at 1.02 and Herbert at 1.04/1.05 range. Rhamondre is a mid 8th.

So 1.05/8.05
for 1.02

It's fair but I'm holding Mahomes. Rhamondre doesn't really move the needle... but it is more interesting given that this is best ball. Fair deal overall.

[Hankybro21]

I'd keep Mahomes. I like him, but who knows what Stevenson does in that offense. I'd need a better/more reliable piece coming back

[Dynasty_Analyst]

Stevenson has no value in a trade like this he’s 1/300th of the value in this trade. If you simply like Herbert more than mahomes sure but I’d take Mahomes. Mahomes Allen and Herbert are very close though

[Edgy68]

I feel like you can do better. This really depends on how much you like Herbert vs Mahomes. From a rankings standpoint, Mahomes has been going after Josh Allen at 1.02 and Herbert at 1.04/1.05 range. Rhamondre is a mid 8th.

So 1.05/8.05
for 1.02

It's fair but I'm holding Mahomes. Rhamondre doesn't really move the needle... but it is more interesting given that this is best ball. Fair deal overall.

Echoing the “look for a better piece” sentiment. I think Herbert is a little better than Mahomes (outscored him this year), but I can respect those who feel Mahomes is ahead. That said, Stevenson doesn’t move the needle on what is at best a lateral move.