Barkley/Hopkins or Jefferson/Jones

[TaquitoPeddler]

10 team, non ppr, 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 2 Flex, 1 TE

Probably should keep the team below as is, but after losing in the championship game 3 years in a row I can’t stop tinkering with it. I traded for Barkley in the offseason, but now have this offer on the table.

My: Saquon and Hopkins
for
His: Justin Jefferson and Aaron Jones

Jefferson would be a great get, despite the non-PPR, and the injuries/Giants sucking do have me concerned about Barkley. But I’m already loaded at WR and if Barkley hits he could possibly be the weapon I need to counter the Kamaras and Henrys who keep knocking me out at the end of seasons.

QB: Mahomes, Tannehill
WR: Tyreek, Hopkins, Diggs, AJ Brown, Aiyuk, Jeudy, Dionte, OBJ, C.Davis, B Edwards
RB: Taylor, Barkley, Mixon, Harris, Edmonds, Gus, Hines, Gurley
TE: Kittle, Goedert, Engram

[abloom]

I'm okay with this. You're buying back a bunch of years at wr and moving off saquan who has had 2 injury shortened seasons and coming off an ACL injury. ACL injuries in rbs tend to be 2 year injuries with the first year being lost completely and the 2nd year hampered by compensation injuries (see dalvin cook). Additionally the damage done to the knee tends to reduce their career length.

[Gator Sens]

Long term, I would take the Jefferson side too. He looks like a beast and despite age, Jones is elite also.

[HughHoney]

Barkley and Hopkins for me.