Dynasty League Football Forum

Hey everyone,

Keeper deadline is fast approaching and i am hoping you guys can give me a bit of advice on who i should keep!

I am in a 5 Keeper standard scoring league and have N.Chubb and D.Henry locked as my keepers already. If you could pick between JK Dobbins or A.Gibson who would you keep?


________________________________________________________________

This is a 8 team standard scoring league.

1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 1K

QB: R.Wilson, J.Burrow
RB: N.CHUBB. D.HENRY, A.GIBSON, J.DOBBINS,B.SCOTT
WR: O.BECKHAM JR , C.GODWIN, B.COOKS,H.RUGGS, T.HIGGINS
TE: T.KELCE, E.EBRON
K: W.Lutz, K.FAIRBAIRN

I like Gibson's opportunity a touch more with Jackson taking carries and goalline/redzone touches, but I think Dobbins is the better player. Tough call but I would lean Gibson based on all factors.

I agree a tough call b/c they are both in different offensive scheme but with two QBs that don't throw the ball a whole lot.

I am hoping that Ron Rivera can scheme and take what he learned from CMC and apply it at Wash * fingers crosses**

Have to say I agree with Gator.

It is a tough call to make, and as a player I prefer Dobbins talent. But from a production standpoint it feels like Gibson is the safer bet. Too bad you have such a difficult decision to make regarding your roster.

No trades allowed? If they are, you could bundle the two of them for a rb you like more to a team that doesn’t have as good of a 5th keeper.

I think Dobbins has a better chance at being a 20-25+ touch guy than Gibson does. Gibson may have a safer floor. I’d take Dobbins

Baltimore is looking like a "3-headed monster" with LJax, Dobbins and Gus.. it's a big monster, but that just limit Dobbins at becoming the #1 RB overall.

Vs Gibson who has legitimate RB1 overall upside. McKissic does lower that passing potential somewhat but still much better than splitting with your 1,000 yd rushing QB and getting vultured at the goal line by both your QB and RB2.