Dynasty League Football Forum

I have a feeling I will get to choose between these QBs.. I didn't think I was going to have a shot at one of those QBs this season, but I traded Russ Wilson for a pick to land one of these guys.
so who do you like more and why?
QBs score 4pt TDs and 1/20yds -2 for an int and -1 for a sack

thanks for the help.. I appreciate it

I think this is pure preference. Both project similarly based on style of play and skill set. Fields seems a bit safer based on where he played and what he showed. Both have big upside and risk. I think Fields gets a shot immediately while Lance may have to wait a bit, but all that is yet to be seen. Pick your favorite of the two.

Gator Sens wrote: ↑Mon Jun 07, 2021 11:31 am I think this is pure preference. Both project similarly based on style of play and skill set. Fields seems a bit safer based on where he played and what he showed. Both have big upside and risk. I think Fields gets a shot immediately while Lance may have to wait a bit, but all that is yet to be seen. Pick your favorite of the two.

I agree with everything above. I think Fields will sit out at least the first few games, but I think he will start early in the season. I would not even hazard a guess as to when Lance will start (could be right away or next season but more likely somewhere in between that). I am always torn in this debate because I think Fields seems like the better player, but his landing spot is not good. Lance has a premium landing spot, but is more of an unknown. If someone made me pick, I would probably roll the dice on Lance, but it wouldn’t be difficult to change my mind. Interesting side note, in all the drafts I have been in, Fields always goes before Lance.

I had both of them fairly close, so for me it's just landing spot, I trust 49ers and their already stacked team long term more than the Bears.

I'll be following this thread. My draft with this choice won't be until mid-August, so I have all Summer to agonize.
Good luck!
-oo-

I had to make this same decision and I went with Lance .I trust that Shanahan offense and they threw alot of draft capital at him. Plus his rushing ability gives him a top 5 QB ceiling

Fields...following the talent.

atlmoneyman wrote: ↑Tue Jun 15, 2021 4:15 pm Fields...following the talent.

This. He played much much much tougher competition.

I've taken Fields, and actually traded the chance to grab lance in favor of Chase.

You can talk Shanahan all you want, but the guy is raw and I still think Jimmy G has a shot to prove it. Injury has always been the issue there.

I am just a firm believer that with QB's landing spot is not important to me. If a QB is a star, he will be a star anywhere and lift those around him. Fields has an alpha #1WR and a RB coming off a great year, not sure why Chicago is deemed such an awful landing spot. I think Lance probably has a hgher ceiling, but there hasn't been a QB come into the league since I can remember that is as raw as him and has such a low floor. If I am forced to choose between the two, Fields is my answer