Dynasty League Football Forum

Sig 1

Someone came to me asking about Keenan, came in a little hot with offering 3 younger receivers.

Give: Keenan & Gurley
Get: Boyd, Curtis Samuel, Marquise Brown

Keenan is like old reliable to me and just enjoy having him. The other receivers are a little iffy to me only because there’s so much competition in their spots. I like the age and talent but not sure they hold up. It does give me flexibility in depth too.

Boyd's side by a lot. But if I'm you, I'd focus my resources on improving the RB room, not the WR one.

I would prefer to hold Allen. Allen is better than Boyd and the others dont close the gap for me, but I'm not a big C. Samuel believer and Baltimore brought in multiple wr's.

Allen easily. He's offering you three pieces of WR-Flex bronze for your WR2 silver.
Hint: 3 bronze < 1 Silver

Anteaters wrote: ↑Sat May 08, 2021 4:50 pm Allen easily. He's offering you three pieces of WR-Flex bronze for your WR2 silver.
Hint: 3 bronze < 1 Silver

This is simply untrue. Sometimes 3 bronze is > 1 silver.
Mixon + Sanders + Jacobs >> Henry

As bad as it is, you can't really afford to lose Gurley. Gotta keep Keenan.

I would rather hold Allen. I think his volume is safe and showed a nice connection with Herbert.

Anteaters wrote: ↑Sat May 08, 2021 4:50 pm Allen easily. He's offering you three pieces of WR-Flex bronze for your WR2 silver.
Hint: 3 bronze < 1 Silver

Depends on how many you start each week.

For me this one simply comes down to are you competing this year or not. If you think you have a shot, I'm holding Allen easily. If you think you might need to retool a little bit, I'm taking the 3 young WR's. But, I'm also trying to get a pick or RB or something thrown in with them to help you out more.

tsarpepe wrote: ↑Sat May 08, 2021 6:39 pm

Anteaters wrote: ↑Sat May 08, 2021 4:50 pm Allen easily. He's offering you three pieces of WR-Flex bronze for your WR2 silver.
Hint: 3 bronze < 1 Silver

This is simply untrue. Sometimes 3 bronze is > 1 silver.
Mixon + Sanders + Jacobs >> Henry

Comparing the RB trio of Mixon+Sanders+Jacobs to the WR trio of Boyd+CSamuel+Hollywood is comparing apples to kumquat. Each of those RBs is at least a high-end RB2 and arguably RB1. Each of those WRs project to be low end WR3/Flex. Each of the RBs is ranked anywhere from 11-18. Each of the WRs is ranked from 27-44.

A better comparison would be
Fournette+Drake+DJohnson < Henry
I'd take those three pieces of bronze if Henry was my only RB. But if I had Henry+Mixon with Gaskins as my flex on a contender, there is no way I'm trading Henry for those guys. Just as there's no way I'm trading Keenan for Boyd+ if I had a contender.

Allen for me. You have Ayuick and Chark on the bench already. You don't need three more non starters for that team.

I would consider it if you could flip some of those WRs for some RBs but I can't imagine that would happen.

I think it's a good time to buy Boyd and Brown CHEAP, but I don't see this as cheap. I just sold Boyd for cheap. I will probably regret it but you should be able to get those guys cheap after this draft. They took big hits in value with Chase and Batemon coming to town.

Chase, Higgins and Boyd could all end the season with 850-900 yds and be low end WR2s. That is a real possibility.

Allen is locked for 150+ targets and will finish as a Top 10 WR most likely in PPR. The combination of safe floor and the week winning boom games makes Allen the anchor on my team.

No way I'm giving him up unless it's for an elite player or early enough draft capital to take a shot on getting that type of player.

tsarpepe wrote: ↑Sat May 08, 2021 6:39 pm

Anteaters wrote: ↑Sat May 08, 2021 4:50 pm Allen easily. He's offering you three pieces of WR-Flex bronze for your WR2 silver.
Hint: 3 bronze < 1 Silver

This is simply untrue. Sometimes 3 bronze is > 1 silver.
Mixon + Sanders + Jacobs >> Henry

None of those 3 are “bronze” equivalents here, very poor comparison.

I’ll take Allen pretty easily in this format. Only taking the package in a very deep league, or maybe best ball.

I would hold Allen.