Dynasty League Football Forum

Which player would you rather have in dynasty?

Edwards has an open path to the WR1 for the Raiders now that Agholor is gone. (I'm a major Ruggs doubter)

Coincidentally, does Agholor (and the TEs) to the Patriots kill N'Keal Harry's chances to finally put together a good season?

Is Harry+a 2022 3rd too much to trade for B. Edwards?

Edwards seems like a decent gamble now. Neither have done anything and are big question marks. Harry really needs the trade rumors to become reality. I'm not sure the Harry offer would be enough since Edwards is an unknown, so could in theory be much better.

I still have some belief in Harry but he needs out of New England. Newton is a terrible passer and no catcher can be successful with him based on last year.

Edwards. It's not much but he still has some value after a bad rookie year and will be seen as a DJ Chark like breakout if he steps up next year

N'Keal Harry from now on will get the Devante Parker treatment of skepticism

I would rather gamble on Edwards. I think Ruggs has far more NFL value than fantasy value as a field stretcher and big play threat, which actually help Edwards if he can get the looks.

I don't think that offer would get you Edwards with most owners. I drafted Edwards and was very disappointed, but it does appear the team is ready to give him the shot at WR1 this year. I prefer Edwards.

Yeah I’d happily shoot that shot if that gets it done somehow. In my heart of hearts I still believe in Harry (hoping against hope), but playing probability here Edwards seems like the guy you’d rather have for upside.

That being said, if I were the Edwards owner, the 22 3rd wouldn’t be enough for me.

I think Harry needs a trade, and as a Pats fan I think Bill is too proud to sell a 1st rounder for at most a 4th. Then again, he's cut a half dozen 2nd rounders in years 2/3.

As an Edwards owner I am patient. He's a guy with pretty big potential, not that Harry doesn't have huge potential in his own right.

Realistically, neither has a big sample. Harry was on IR most of his rookie year, then had Cam's wet noodle of an arm throwing balls into the ground. That said, he was CLEARLY passed on the depth chart by Jakobi Myers and Damiere Byrd. Part of draft capital is the guarantee of opportunity. Unfortunately that doesn't ride in NE. With offseason additions and maybe the return of Edelman, Harry is the 4th receiver on an offense that will be running a lot of 21 sets still quarterbacked by Cam Newton. I'll pass.

Both have a lot to prove and both have issues. Harry has had a few years in the league and has done nothing. There were doubts of him coming out of college and those doubters may be true. Furthermore, Harry doesn't have good separation skills and has been called out by Bill B on several occasions-NOT GOOD. Edwards would seem a better bet but his issue is that he tends to get a lot of nagging injuries and for the time being he will behind Waller in looks. It will be interesting to see how much of an impact John B will have on his minutes in 2021.

But to answer your question I would go with Edwards but as of now I wouldn't pay to much for him. Good luck!!!

Edwards is on a team that needs a WR to step up, while Harry is on a team that spent money this offseason trying to improve the position. Even with the John Brown signing, I’m going Edwards

logan_roy wrote: ↑Wed Mar 31, 2021 7:48 pm Edwards is on a team that needs a WR to step up, while Harry is on a team that spent money this offseason trying to improve the position. Even with the John Brown signing, I’m going Edwards

Agree, I think the Brown signing is more an indication what the organization thinks of Ruggs then Edwards.