DJ+ or CMC+?

[bkfakefootball]

Hi, just wanted to see what side you like? Not for a team in the Sig but the DJ team also has Mixon for a 2RB 2WR 2Flex 1/2 ppr league. Thanks!

[Gator Sens]

I would take the David Johnson side. More upside young players coming back.

[Cowboysfan33]

DJ side for me too.

[Kmani6]

I would take the David Johnson side. More upside young players coming back.

While this is true, CMC is the best upside young player in the trade by far. In RB years the 4.5 year age difference between DJ and CMC is everything . The CMC side is getting the two best pieces I would stick with it.

[jwconnel]

CMC is definitely the best piece, but I still like the DJ side here. Moore and Kirk are both young upcoming WR's, Mack could have a great year with a few more weapons in that offense, and the wheels are bound to fall off for Julio in the next year or two. Coleman disappointed last year and the RBBC show in SF isn't going to be pretty this year.

[Kmani6]

What makes you think the wheels are bound to fall off for Julio so soon? The fact that he just had his best year in the last 3 years by far? Julio is going to be golden for the next 3 years don't think about it too much. In fact I'd argue Julio will be productive longer then David Johnson will...

[mrmagloo]

Give me the Julio CMC side. Not a fan of a bunch for a bunch trades though.

[jwconnel]

Julio is going to be productive this year and maybe next, but 32 is typically the "cliff" for receivers and he's 30.5. Even ignoring that, his value is already starting to fall. By next year, he'll be like AJG now. I can't get anywhere close to AJ's value on the market. Julio may break the trend and produce for 3-4 more years, but I think you're choosing to go down with the ship if you keep him past this season. That's just my two cents. I'm also probably higher than most on Moore and Kirk.

[mrmagloo]

Julio is going to be productive this year and maybe next, but 32 is typically the "cliff" for receivers and he's 30.5. Even ignoring that, his value is already starting to fall. By next year, he'll be like AJG now. I can't get anywhere close to AJ's value on the market. Julio may break the trend and produce for 3-4 more years, but I think you're choosing to go down with the ship if you keep him past this season. That's just my two cents. I'm also probably higher than most on Moore and Kirk.

I will deal with the cliff when it happens, for next 2-3 years, I want Julio and CMC. That is a hammer and anvil, not a hammer in search of an anvil...

[QB Browns]

I'm 100% on the CMC side here. If you're that worried about Julio falling off then move him for picks because he's still an elite player right now and someone will pay up for him. The age difference between McCaffrey and Johnson is big for me too, but I also think McCaffrey is the more talented player of the two and is set to put up huge numbers for a pretty long time. Johnson has a similar career timeline to Julio in my mind

[bkfakefootball]

Thanks for the reply’s. I was really wanting CMC and this was the only trade the other owner would do. I like all the young players on the DJ side but felt like with Mixon & CMC it could put me over the top