Trade complete-Good, Bad or Meh?

[hoggball]

So I posted a topic yesterday about trading for CD and giving 3 firsts. After negotiations, we came to the following deal.
I gave: 1.07, 1.11 and Golladay
I got: CD, 3.01, 4.06
GOOD, BAD OR MEH?

[BradysBunch]

Great for you.

[Fantasy>>>Reality]

Ya I like it

[thomasscheeks]

This seems a lot like a brag post to me.. lol. Great trade for you. Davis was a consensus 1.01-1.02 pick last year

[jwb32]

CD side by a lot

[murphysxm]

This seems a lot like a brag post to me.. lol. Great trade for you. Davis was a consensus 1.01-1.02 pick last year

c

While I agree with the sentiment, because I like the player, I hate factoring in where somebody was taken in the past in evaluating value today. Are Treadwell and White still worth what they were when they were taken 1.3 in rookie drafts?

[Mkh3225]

Solid move, esp since you didn't need to give up all 3 firsts

[hoggball]

This seems a lot like a brag post to me.. lol. Great trade for you. Davis was a consensus 1.01-1.02 pick last year

Not a brag post at all man. I make alot of trades. Some good, some crazy stupid. I like to get feedback once in a while from the community...as we all do.
In a previous post, most of the feedback was keep the 3 1sts. I thought this trade was alot to give. Golladay is an older second year player playing 3rd fiddle but may be just as promising of a prospect. He just doesn't have the draft pedigree as CD. Is he a better sell in the deal over the 1.10???
1.07 could possibly net the best receiver (and landing spot) this year. The 1.11 is a little more of a dart throw but you never know prior to the draft.
Man I hope CD becomes what we all think he can.
Anyways...sorry to rant. Thanks for all the feedback.

[Goddard]

So you got to swap out a 1st with Golladay? That's a great deal.

[Cowboysfan33]

So I posted a topic yesterday about trading for CD and giving 3 firsts. After negotiations, we came to the following deal.
I gave: 1.07, 1.11 and Golladay
I got: CD, 3.01, 4.06
GOOD, BAD OR MEH?

I think it’s definitely a win for you but I don’t think other side is that bad either, I like Golladay though so that makes a difference.

[Mephistopheles]

I think it's a good trade for both sides. If Golladay pops it would increase the value of that side.

[jpusmc0311]

Good, but not great..

[thomasscheeks]

This seems a lot like a brag post to me.. lol. Great trade for you. Davis was a consensus 1.01-1.02 pick last year

Not a brag post at all man. I make alot of trades. Some good, some crazy stupid. I like to get feedback once in a while from the community...as we all do.
In a previous post, most of the feedback was keep the 3 1sts. I thought this trade was alot to give. Golladay is an older second year player playing 3rd fiddle but may be just as promising of a prospect. He just doesn't have the draft pedigree as CD. Is he a better sell in the deal over the 1.10???
1.07 could possibly net the best receiver (and landing spot) this year. The 1.11 is a little more of a dart throw but you never know prior to the draft.
Man I hope CD becomes what we all think he can.
Anyways...sorry to rant. Thanks for all the feedback.

I wasn't hating. I was just messing with you. lol