How much to sell AJ Green for?

[bbsmitz]

I took over a team this year that's in disarray (below) and I've been trying to rebuild. Another owner keeps asking how much for AJ Green.

He offered me two mid/late 2018 1sts which seemed laughably low. I'm thinking about countering for the 2018 1sts plus Mike Williams. Is that enough? I feel like that's still a little light, but I don't want to ask for another 1st and be offensive.

Other young players on his squad are Kamara, Martavis Bryant, Crowder and Snead.

[QuintorrisLopezJones]

still way too low. if that's all he has I'd probably look for a different partner

[Generic Username]

Give him M Lee for one of those late 1sts...AJG is still AJG and requires high value assets to acquire

[dblj1199]

Have you let the entire league know your shopping AJ? Create a little battle amongst owners to drive his price up. I'd possibly try for Kamara, Williams, 1sts for AJ and Lee, or your lowest 2nd rd pick.

[Goddard]

If two 1sts is laughably low, why would asking for one more be offensive? I agree with shopping him around to the rest of your league and make sure they all know he's available. Let them fight over him and bid against themselves.

[bbsmitz]

Have you let the entire league know your shopping AJ? Create a little battle amongst owners to drive his price up. I'd possibly try for Kamara, Williams, 1sts for AJ and Lee, or your lowest 2nd rd pick.

I have, but people seem to be really stingy. I haven't really gotten any solid offers for him.

still way too low. if that's all he has I'd probably look for a different partner

What if I asked for his 2019 1st as well. So that'd be 3 mid/late 1sts and Williams.

Thanks for everyone's help. I'm obviously new to Dynasty.

[bbsmitz]

If two 1sts is laughably low, why would asking for one more be offensive? I agree with shopping him around to the rest of your league and make sure they all know he's available. Let them fight over him and bid against themselves.

Good point. I guess I'm still trying to peg Green's value. The counter offer I thought of was 3 1sts (mid/late) plus Mike Williams. That's what I was worried might be offensive.

[lukkynumber13]

In your situation, I'd sell him for the pair of Firsts and either Bryant or Williams on top

[doctor d]

I think you should definitely ask for the 3 1sts and Williams. I don't think it's outrageous, especially because the '18 firsts will be late and the '19 first is a year out. People are really low on Williams. If you're selling green, I think you need a good shot at a stud back, or at least the four good flyers.

[Moneyball_85]

I was just offered AJG, Amendola, and OJ Howard for CMC, Corey Davis, and Cooper Kupp. I turned it down, but I feel like it will take a ton to get AJG..almost an overpay.

[Goddard]

If two 1sts is laughably low, why would asking for one more be offensive? I agree with shopping him around to the rest of your league and make sure they all know he's available. Let them fight over him and bid against themselves.

Good point. I guess I'm still trying to peg Green's value. The counter offer I thought of was 3 1sts (mid/late) plus Mike Williams. That's what I was worried might be offensive.

Gotcha...I thought you meant just 3 1sts. I'd make that counter and see what happens. I still don't think it would be offensive at all, especially since he's the one going after AJG.

[bbsmitz]

Gotcha...I thought you meant just 3 1sts. I'd make that counter and see what happens. I still don't think it would be offensive at all, especially since he's the one going after AJG.

Well, I countered with that and he accepted. I'm hoping this isn't a dollar for 4 quarters type of trade but it'll give me some flexibility in the draft and with rebuilding.

Thank you all for your help!

[Vcize]

I think that's a good trade for a rebuilding team.

[Dynasty DeLorean]

3 1sts and Mike Williams. I can't argue with that although I would have liked to secure an early 1st. But you have the ammo to move up in the draft if you need to. Next offseason after we go through the draft process, keep in mind you can package up 2 of those 1sts (or a 1st and something else) to move up if you don't like anyone in the mid-late area.